Best panther ever

[PantherPride]

Steve Smith is and always will be the greatest Carolina Panther.

[Kakarot]

It's definitely Steve Smith. Steve Smith is the heart and soul of the Panthers; he is the Carolina Panthers.

[merchman567]

Beurlien

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Depends. The best player on the field… You can't beat 89.

But on and off the field, I do believe Sam Mills deserves to be recognized.

[DudeNamedJeremy]

i gotta go with pep

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Depends. The best player on the field… You can't beat 89.

But on and off the field, I do believe Sam Mills deserves to be recognized.

[Mayor Qumiby]

The main reason I made this thread was to see how it would be interpreted it, be it on/field factors or both. Plus I wanted to see if there was a diffence on newer fans and those who were with the team from day one... As for me I wasnt really a football fan until Charlotte got it's team and even then I was just a casual fan . I pulled for them because they were the hometown team but I really didn't become a diehard fan until the 2003 season. I remember the exact moment to, it was when smitty got that td from the infamous x-clown...

Anyways since im a newer fan Its easy for me to pick smitty I just didn't know if it was the overall consenus orrr if older fans had held a player in a higher reguard.

[KillerKat]

So a player that punches his teammates and is a dick to Panther fans is the greatest Panther of all time? Ok, sureeeeee.

[Mayor Qumiby]

Yuppp but your missing alot of good parts. I guess you can view the glass half empty if you like

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

So a player that punches his teammates and is a dick to Panther fans is the greatest Panther of all time? Ok, sureeeeee.

As a player, he's a monster. As a person, guys like Sam Mills and D-Lo among others are much higher than Steve. He can be respectful, but when he gets into the game… It can get ugly.

[KillerKat]

Yuppp but your missing alot of good parts. I guess you can view the glass half empty if you like

If you're talking just on the field, then you have a case. But when I think of "Best Panther of All-Time", I think of the best well rounded player that gave the most to this organization. And that is Mills hands down.

[Mayor Qumiby]

That's what's cool about this thread we can each have our own opinion and nobodys wrong!! I aknowledge his altercations but i don't let affect how I veiw him

But your not wrong either Sam mills was the man and did alot of great things but IMO smitty just is #1

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Same. I love Steve and i think he's probably a good guy. I mean, he's got a bit of an ego and a short temper, but he does seem like a good, respectable guy. But Sam Mills was the real deal. All around, on and off the field. You didn't have to assume he was a good person. You just knew.

[Steel Panther]

:iagree: