Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

American Idol tiers


g5jamz

Recommended Posts

as of March 29 - and my opinion only. I feel that more women watch it than men, and that's why you've seen the "bad" women out first. I think we'll start seeing the "bad" men from tier 3 fall the next few weeks, with maybe a surprise in Tier 2, but doubtful.

Tier 1 (in no particular order)

Casey James - mad guitar skillz...but he needs to spit the dip out before singing

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Mike Lynche - solid

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Crystal Bowersox - she's still got a couple of shades of teeth whitening left...but insane good

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Siobhan Magnus - still a favorite, but ditzy as heck

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Tier 2

Aaron Kelly - looks like a caricature or a Mad Magazine character.

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Lee Dewyze - don't know if America is ready for another soul patrol...

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Katie Stevens - has disappointed but she's got crazy skills. Hope the next time she belts it out and doesn't sound so suppressed.

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Didi Benami - niche voice...tough to win a competition with that voice. Reminds me of the one-armed tattoo chick from last year

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tier 3 - one should go home this week...

Andrew Garcia - was awful last week. Don't know what to say...thought he was amazing at the outset, but fallen off badly. I mean off a cliff bad. Has to get original...in a good way.

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Tim Urban - no relation to Keith Urban. Has had one good week...that's about it. I didn't think last week's was horrible, but he's not in the same class.

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Move Katie Stevens & Casey James down a level and you'd have it right.

Katie needs a few years with a coach before she is ready. Great raw talent but no control and little idea what to do with it.

Casey is just a mediocre vocalist on his best day.

I could see that...

I guess I was just tiering based on what I think the general public thinks. I don't see Casey in any danger of being voted out for quite a while.

Talentwise...I would agree with you. I'll do a prediction tiering post-Tuesday performances.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • He should've been more than a JAG, but Jeremy Chinn.  I was convinced he was our next defensive star 
    • I see what you did there
    • Yeah the only way current set up is fun is if every year a different tiny school builds a super team and makes a run. You just need 1 rich guy to say you know what would be funny, if I drop 30 million and my school has a shot at a national championship.   They won't ever do it but put some sort of tiered salary cap in place and sign them to 4 year deals. You can only transfer up or down tiers no lateral moves because mean ole coach at texas doesn't play me enough so I'm going to Tennessee. So a player at prairie view can transfer to texas and get paid more or a player from UNC can transfer to UNCG because he isn't getting playing time. If a guy is transferring "up" he can get a salary bump if the team has salary cap space. A guy transferring down has to stay at the same salary as he signed his 4 year deal for so the lower tier team would have to have the cap space to sign him. It would stop the money chasing for lateral moves but allow guys who improve massively at lower schools to make more money as juniors and seniors and hopefully keep more guys in one place because the contract is for 4 years.
×
×
  • Create New...