Would you trade Williams for Big Ben?

[Wither]

one point that people miss about our running game is that it employs 2 1st round rb talents. there are other teams that have better or equal ground games with out this luxury. we will lose one of these guys one day. just depends on who it is.

And you try to keep them as long as you can until they are finally split up instead of making retarded moves that gets rid of them directly and sooner.

[Cardiac Cat]

Great story. Compelling, and rich

[TheSaint]

no need to get your panties in a wad. Its obvious Carolina isnt going to make any moves this offseason...just a thought.

And like someone said, you arent gonna keep the two RBs together forever. You need to get the most value you can, when you can. The key is to judge that ideal time.

[PantherPhann]

NO, absolutely not. As a matter of fact there is no one in the NFL that I would trade D. Will for. Yeah, thats right i said it.... No One. We are a running team 1st and in order to run you need a dynamic RB and thats D Will. We don't have to have a P. Manning, just a good to very good QB.

[R0CKnR0LLA]

Besides the obvious character concerns we already have our QB for the future. We need two good RBs, not two good QBs.

[Doc Holiday]

Speaking from personal expirience it would be a bad idea for the Panthers to trade Williams for anyone.

I've met Williams and Beason(as well as many others) playing paintball and had a lot of conversation with both of them and I can say for fact that it will be a bad thing to see them go anywhere.

Williams is the only player the panther have ever had that I'm a bigger fan of then the team, I will always be a D-Will fan if he's a Panther or not.

[Jangler]

Yup, this is a thread.

[PantherDude]

The only one who would suggest this shitty idea is an 'Aints fan who want to see our team hit rock bottom. That why he suggest one of the dumbest idea in this thread. He doesn't want us to success like he talk: he just want us to fail & that is by getting rid one of our best player with a QB that is in trouble recently. :sosp:

Though I think it's too early to call Big Ben a "rapist". Most will accuse him of rape because he is rich & a celebrity. Innocent until proven guilty.

[Pumpkin King]

I thought this was a Panthers forum.

[Maxie]

Yup, this is a thread.

LOL, you can tell it's a good question just by the answers. Everything from resounding "yes" es to emphatic "no's"

[The Don]

hahahahahahahahahahahaha (lmfao!!!) all kinds of win in that, oh man that's hilarious!

[Gscottnc5]

No!!! he will try to force himself on(some call it rape, I know thats what I call it) on the women of Charlotte if that were to happen. He is a piece of poo!!! From a moral standpoint, he doesn't deserve the money he makes.

[88 Bronco]

Hell yeah I want this guy for a QB

Opps I meant this guy

Maybe it was this guy

No it had to be this one

Nevermind

[Guest silver82blade]

NO, absolutely not. As a matter of fact there is no one in the NFL that I would trade D. Will for. Yeah, thats right i said it.... No One. We are a running team 1st and in order to run you need a dynamic RB and thats D Will. We don't have to have a P. Manning, just a good to very good QB.

you wouldn't trade williams for chris johnson? ok then. good running backs in this league are a dime a dozen. lots of teams have two, some have three. it's the deepest position in football today, with linebacker a close second. i'd really have to think about that trade long and hard. i'd probably hook ben up to a lie detector 3 or 4 times and ask him some questions. there's no other way you're going to get any remote sense of what actually happened.