Panther games where you thought the cats were cheated, or most cheated/rigged

[PantherProfessor]

well, the big one is of course Bellicheat during the SB.

but i think there have been plenty of bad calls against big market teams (giants, cowgirls, ETC..)

[Dpantherman]

and one last time....here is the play live...(around :55) http://www.nfl.com/videos/carolina-panthers/09000d5d8055a86c/Week-16-Q4-Cowboys-at-Panthers-Video-Highlights-2007

[Dpantherman]

and Bryant Gumble blows

[Darth Bobo]

Yep Dallas game where we tipped the kick, and then coincidentally hit their kicker. IN replay, you could clearly see the kick suddenly change course after crossing Pep's fingers.

Changed the outcome of the game. I still say a Superbowl team has to win in spite of bad calls.

[PantherBrew]

Dallas game, and its not even close.

[carolinarolls]

peppers tipped the ball..nothing else comes close

[VGcollector]

dallas 07 makes me hate them more, first the drew carter pass interference, then the steve smith incomp which at worst should have been a fumble like if they called a fumble i wolud be pissed but i wold have atleast said i can barely say that but to say it wasnt a catch... then the matt moore got hit a couple of times i thought was questionable. it is wierd to think that fox could have gone to playoff 7 out of 8 years,

2003 we did go, 2004 little cloudy but i think it was the saints game that messed us over, 2005 we wnt, 2006 little cloudy as well but i think if giants had missed field go and loss to redskins we go to playoffs, 2007 dallas game, 2008 we went, 2009 pats game. Anyway thats my rant before our football game

[PhillyB]

The 07 Dallas game was the worst officiating I've ever seen. We were the better team that night. What's funny is that if we had won that game we would have made the playoffs.

this one, hands down. carter was being stripped and buttraped for ten yards and not one call.

[Phil Dees]

peppers tipped the ball..nothing else comes close

Yeah but Peppers said himself he didn't.

It was Lucas that claimed to have tipped the ball:

December 25, 2005|From the Associated Press

CHARLOTTE, N.C. — Ken Lucas and Julius Peppers pushed through the line, grasping at air in an effort to block Billy Cundiff's field-goal try.

Lucas was positive his left middle finger touched the ball right before he and Peppers crashed into the kicker. The deflection changed the trajectory, caused Cundiff's attempt to miss and locked up a postseason berth for the Carolina Panthers.

Peppers was called for roughing the kicker, giving the Dallas Cowboys a second chance to keep their fading playoff hopes alive.

"Definitely I touched the ball, both me and God know it, but I guess it wasn't enough to turn the play over," Lucas said. "Besides that, that wasn't roughing the kicker. Me and Pep landed on the ground and the kicker just fell over us.

But....that ain't the rule !

A member of the receiving team may not run into or rough a kicker who kicks from behind his line unless contact is:

(a) Incidental to and after he had touched ball in flight.

( Caused by kicker’s own motions.

© Occurs during a quick kick, or a kick made after a run behind the line, or after kicker recovers a loose ball on the ground. Ball is loose when kicker muffs snap or snap hits ground.

(d) Defender is blocked into kicker.

Keyword "he". Lucas touched, Peppers penalized.

[brandon_87]

So it's self explanatory. Name the panther games that you thought refs had severely screwed us.

The 07 Dallas game was the worst officiating I've ever seen. We were the better team that night. What's funny is that if we had won that game we would have made the playoffs.

Actually now that I think about it almost every Dallas game there are some bullshit calls. The 05 game where Peppers blocked the field goal, but "hit" the kicker.

Those are some that come to mind. Post yours.

u mean how they can basically tackle King on 3rd down before the ball gets there but we get near Witten on 3rd and long and they call a PI? I was so fuging heated on that bullshit