American Idol

[Hawk]

I had a hard time understanding some of his lyrics when he sang as well. I originally liked his unique voice though.

[g5jamz]

Good show last night.

Think Scotty, Jacob, and Casey were weakest of the bunch.

Jacob should go home if not just for dressing like a flamboyant Farahkhan bodyguard.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Scotty killed it Wed night.

I don't think Casey deserved to go, but I still want Haley to win it regardless.

[Mr. Scot]

"Want her to win it" or just plain "want her"? :lol:

[g5jamz]

Good...Casey's done. Very talented kid and will do fine, but the public can only take so much Cocker.

[Hawk]

yup...was a fan, and I like to watch him on stage as he does put on a show each time, but the singing really didn't improve much for me...think this still comes down to James vs Jacob, but I've also become a huge fan of the country chick too...she ate Scotty up and spat him out in their duet.

[Zaximus]

I think Lauren is improving week to week more than ANY singer in the competition. Her, and James at this point seem to be improving the most to me.

Haley is gone next week I'm sure (sadly) and Jacob doesn't seem to be a big favorite. I'm surprised Scotty was so low but I'm kind of bored of him too.

I think top 3 will be James/Scotty/Lauren though.

[Hawk]

James/Lauren/Jacob for me....Jacob is growing on me...he's toned down the dramatics!

[sunbunny]

My pick is still James. I do like Haley.

It wouldn't surprise me for Scotty to win it, though.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

End of thread, end of season.

[Dpantherman]

Hailey KILLED it.

WTF was Jacob thinking picking Jordin sparks? hes gone.

[Hawk]

Jacob went back to over singing, in my opinion. Hailey nailed House of the Rising Sun and I also really liked James. He's pitchy at times but I think you put him in a studio and he's gonna sell albums. Really have become a fan of Lauren.

[sunbunny]

Jacob is the only one I didn't like at all last night.

[Goosfraba21]

That performance by Hailey last night may be the best one idol has ever seen. If not the best its up there.