Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Rosario is a more efficient pass blocker than King...


CatMan72

Recommended Posts

Barnridge did not have a catch last year. However, in 09 he had 12 catches for a 20.2 yards per catch average. With a long of 55. But for the life of me I cannot remember a single one. Not sure what happened last year for him not to get a single reception, because I thought Fox and Hurney were very high on him.

Shockey, Rosario, and Barnridge sound good to me. And GOOOO PANTHERS!!!!!!!!!!!!

I remember a really nice catch and run in the Giants game at the end of the '09 season... I think the downside to Barnidge is that he isn't much of a blocker.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-videos/09000d5d81526582/Gary-Barnidge-Highlight-WK-15-vs-Vikings-2009

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-videos/09000d5d813b6026/Gary-Barnidge-Highlight-WK-07-vs-Bills-2009?r_src=ramp

in training camp that year jake was throwing to him all the time. i thought for sure they had found something special. meanwhile jeff king was sucking it up and dropping to 3rd on the depth chart. only problem was fox/davidson and their loyalty to the older guys. when real game time came up, they went right back to their old ways.

i got no idea what happened with barnidge last year other than being yet another casualty that year of fox/davidson bad playcalling and offense.

Not to hijack the thread, I cannot, for the life of me, understand why Fox was so #@* % stubborn. Everyone figured out Fox but Fox. How a veteran HC could be comfortable with the warmed-over, ultra-conservative, and pathetically predictable playcalling we had to endure the past few years is beyond me. And someone may say, "yeah but we had no problem with the playcalling in 2008...." But after getting embarrased by Arizona in the playoffs, you would think Fox would've at least tweeked the offense playcalling to be more competitive.

Fox was a player's coach and a nice guy, by all accounts, and I'm appreciative of what he did for us taking us to a couple of NFCGs and a Super Bowl. But words cannot express how glad I am that his conservative philosophy is now another teams' problem. /rant

Back to the thread, I'm looking forward to seeing what Barnidge and Rosario can do in this new offensive system.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hidden

Not to hijack the thread, I cannot, for the life of me, understand why Fox was so #@* % stubborn. Everyone figured out Fox but Fox. How a veteran HC could be comfortable with the warmed-over, ultra-conservative, and pathetically predictable playcalling we had to endure the past few years is beyond me. And someone may say, "yeah but we had no problem with the playcalling in 2008...." But after getting embarrased by Arizona in the playoffs, you would think Fox would've at least tweeked the offense playcalling to be more competitive.

Fox was a player's coach and a nice guy, by all accounts, and I'm appreciative of what he did for us taking us to a couple of NFCGs and a Super Bowl. But words cannot express how glad I am that his conservative philosophy is now another teams' problem. /rant

Back to the thread, I'm looking forward to seeing what Barnidge and Rosario can do in this new offensive system.

Fox was stubborn b/c if you gave him what he wanted.......and his team stayed healthy.......his formula pretty much worked enough of the time to have a competitive team. He was flawed. But a healthy Fox team was pretty good. BORING and easy to figure out but it worked.

Link to comment

Not sure where that came from because Rosario has made plenty of catches for the Panthers.:rolleyes5:

Since being with the Panthers he has averaged 20 catches a year and 223 yards. That is a measly 1 catch a game and 14 yards. Say whatever you want, but I refuse to go into a 5th year saying "this is Rosario's break-out year." I hope it is his break-out year, but I have turned that page.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No, but it is interesting that their analysis shows Rosario as a significantly better pass blocking TE than King AND the 4th best in the league over a period of 3 seasons... I don't think most people expected to see that (including the author himself)

the way they grade is so weird though, at least as i understand it (perhaps it has changed). their idea of noting and aggregating positive/negative contributions is a good idea in theory, but they don't even weight contributions which gives you weird things like antoine winfield being an elite cb because he tackles the best (just an example. idk what he was this year but in the past they had him rated very highly).

it's tough to grade w/o knowing roles obv, but in particular it seems extremely difficult to evaluate blocking if you lack complete knowledge of the protection scheme. potential for misattribution errors all over the place

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the way they grade is so weird though, at least as i understand it (perhaps it has changed). their idea of noting and aggregating positive/negative contributions is a good idea in theory, but they don't even weight contributions which gives you weird things like antoine winfield being an elite cb because he tackles the best (just an example. idk what he was this year but in the past they had him rated very highly).

it's tough to grade w/o knowing roles obv, but in particular it seems extremely difficult to evaluate blocking if you lack complete knowledge of the protection scheme. potential for misattribution errors all over the place

winfield single handedly broke the game when the vikings beat us in 08, i can still see him taking that game.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Since being with the Panthers he has averaged 20 catches a year and 223 yards. That is a measly 1 catch a game and 14 yards. Say whatever you want, but I refuse to go into a 5th year saying "this is Rosario's break-out year." I hope it is his break-out year, but I have turned that page.

Once again I am more than a little confused about your comments. It is extremely difficult to have a "Break-out year" when the position you play is a minor component in the offense.

It is extremely hard to rack up stats when you do not get the ball.

Rosario is a product of Foxy and Davidson. The TE was never a priority with them. If you want to downplay his value, you have to look to the coaching staff not your heart.

That said, I know Chud likes the TE. So maybe Rosario will finally get the attention he deserves. It will not be a "Break-out year", because he has already shown he can play. It will be a "Finally year" because he will finally be

given an opportunity to showcase his talent.

Anyway, GOOOOO PANTHERS!!!!!!!!!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i didn't say winfield was bad or something, i said he wasn't elite. vulnerable in coverage, esp on deeper routes and really has to be in zone

edit: also a team that runs the ball a lot, winfield obv has a little extra value against us. roll coverage to smith and he can do his thing against the run

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Once again I am more than a little confused about your comments. It is extremely difficult to have a "Break-out year" when the position you play is a minor component in the offense.

It is extremely hard to rack up stats when you do not get the ball.

Rosario is a product of Foxy and Davidson. The TE was never a priority with them. If you want to downplay his value, you have to look to the coaching staff not your heart.

That said, I know Chud likes the TE. So maybe Rosario will finally get the attention he deserves. It will not be a "Break-out year", because he has already shown he can play. It will be a "Finally year" because he will finally be

given an opportunity to showcase his talent.

Anyway, GOOOOO PANTHERS!!!!!!!!!!!!

I guess time will tell but I think a lot of people are holding out hope with marginal players because "Fox didn't give them a chance, etc." Reality is we had a lot of years where our offense was very productive. The fact that Rosario has had 4 years to beat our Jeff King and he is unable to do that says a lot.

I understand that the TE position was not heavily utilized in our offense, but I honestly think that was based a lot on the fact that we don't have any great tight ends; just a bunch of average ones. Wesley Walls was very successful in Carolina, albeit under a different regime, but under a very similar offense.

Fox is not as bad of a coach as everyone all of a sudden claims. The fact is Rosario has been given many opportunities and he has squandered all of them. I have never seen a TE drop so many passes. This is why he could never beat out King. Every year starts out the same - Rosario starts and show signs of hope and after 4-5 games starts losing reps to King and ends up by midseason taking the back seat. Again, I hope he turns into Antonio Gates, but don't hold your breath.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

probably a healthy combo of Fox not involving TEs much and Clausen not being able to throw over the middle.

Clausen completed 11 balls to the middle of the field w/ an average of 2.96 yards per pass (checkdowns).

That meshes with my memory exactly. It was like he looked at option 1, and if that was not there, his internal clock told him to get rid of the ball. If the play was outside he threw the ball away. If the play was toward the middle of the field he would dump it off.

My recolection of Jimmy last year was a QB that did not want to make a mistake, as opposed to a QB that did want to make plays. He just did not appear to be having any fun, that it was all just such a chore.

As a Michigan State man, I did not want him to begin with. He had never done anything to win me over, which makes how he played last so hard to take. The Panther fan inside me wanted him to succeed. Yet the Spartan fan wanted him to fall on his face. The problem lies in the fact that I found no satisfaction from him doing the latter. I was more consumed by the trials the team faced, with injuries and bad play to name 2, than how he played. It was weird to root for him, but my allegiance to the Panthers outweighed my distain for him.

My problem lies in the fact that although I might not be a Clausen fan, I at least try and calm my thinking by thinking of him as a Panther. And because he is a Panther, I temper my feelings for the individual, for the thrill, or otherwise, of the team. The people that are hating on Cam seem to be taking things very personally. Like Cam somehow dissed them to their face, or did unthinkable things to a loved one. I was under the illusion that the number one rule of being a fan was to support the team? And last I knew Cam was part of the team. Sorry for the rant.

With luck we will not see Clausen on the field this year anyway. And GOOO PANTHERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Iamhubby, you do understand that in one post you say "how can you judge Rosario based on the coaching staff he had to work with," then in the next breath say "hopefully we will not see any Clausen this year."

I hope to not see much of Clausen either, but not really fair to cast him away after only one year with the incompetent coaching staff as you say, then give Rosario another chance after he has had 4 years under the same coaching staff. Not trying to argue, but my point is average players don't normally become great just because they have a new coaching staff. Chud didn't go after Shockey because he was convinced we had the talent at TE.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Iamhubby, you do understand that in one post you say "how can you judge Rosario based on the coaching staff he had to work with," then in the next breath say "hopefully we will not see any Clausen this year."

valid point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Yesterday was predictable and some predicted it.  We were due for that bubble to pop. We were outclassed going into it, coaching staff and roster both.  It doesn’t feel that bad when you predict it but when you have to watch it In real time it is extremely deflating.    
    • Well they better sign him to a decent deal or he walks this year, and we get nothing for him. Actually they could get the same for Chuba and let it be known that Dowdle is our #1 back. I like him but I doubt he will be here next year.
    • The Bills are a well coached team.  I give them that.  They are a well run organization.  That’s no excuse.  The point of this thread is to point out that yesterday illustrated something much more troubling than losing to a good team.  My takeaways: * We still haven’t found a coach.  Canales isn’t it.  He is in way over his head.  Everyone knows how I feel about Bryce, but seeing Dalton yesterday, a lot of the issues Bryce deals with every week are now clearly thematic.  I thought to myself yesterday, “but Ron Rivera looked like he was drowning until that Buffalo game,” and now in hindsight, he ultimately became possibly our greatest coach in franchise history.  But before that Buffalo game with his seat as hot as ever, he did some of the dumbest things I had ever seen.  He refused to adjust.  He played guys that shouldn’t have been out on the field over guys who seemed like clearly better players.  For example, Josh Norman sat for how many seasons, mostly because of non-quantifiable stuff.  Canales suffers the same issues early in his tenure,  it without any of the reassurances or pedigree that Ron had.  Our offense stinks because of Dave, point blank, period.  We can only guess about play calls and scheme because we don’t know all the ins and outs of that, but what is clear is that he has no idea how to put our guys in positions to succeed.  Look at the number of players who have absolutely killed it that Dave tried his best to keep off the field - Rico, Mays, Christensen, Horn, etc.  Now look at the guys he played over them.  Ron only had a couple of those instances over several seasons albeit bad ones *cough* Nakamura *cough* Josh Norman *cough*.  But, Dave is multiplying that by the umpteenth power in one season.  And not only is it about the guys he is or isn’t playing, he doesn’t know how to use them.  All of the TEs.  The aforementioned Horn Jr.  XL.  Trying to make Corbett a center.  Both Rico and Chuba are healthy, but he can’t figure out how to use them together.  There is zero rhythm to the offense most games after that opening drive, and a lot of it is Dave playing guys that shouldn’t be playing and not knowing how to implement the ones that are that could help us the most.  I had held onto hope because Dave’s positivity and his track record with QBs.  But, the more I’ve watched, it has become clear, even in coaching extremely limited QBs, there are so many other issues that falls on coaching that he is responsible for.  He is not a good coach. *Speaking of Rico and Chuba, don’t know if anyone else caught that, but after scoring his garbage time TD that was force fed to him, when Chuba went over to the bench, he sat down seemingly alone.  Then the camera zoomed out and actually Rico was on the other side of that portion of the bench.  Another guy, I’m guessing a practice squad guy came and sat down closer to Chuba but between them, and from what I saw, Rico looked straight ahead.  They never looked at one another, didn’t appear to speak to one another, nothing.  Someone else correct me if I’m wrong, as I was heavily distracted, but if they interacted it would’ve been just a millisecond that I wasn’t looking…  the body language looked absolutely discouraging.  There is clearly a huge beef brewing there. *Back to Canales…  which is a further indictment that this isn’t just schematic or playcalling.  Another reason he is clearly not a good coach - when we lose this season we LOSE.  We lose big.  We lose ugly.  We lose unprepared.  We lose undisciplined.  We lose in every fundamental way.  You don’t go from stifling the #1 offense in the NFL two weeks ago, to getting blown out at home 40-3 (Chuba’s late TD is irrelevant).  In every facet of the game that we have shown improvement, we go out in losses like yesterday’s and make you question if it was fool’s gold.  That’s poor coaching.  It’s discouraging because the drop off isn’t incremental, these are huge wild swings.  From a top 10 defense who excels at stopping the run, to giving up the highest individual rushing day in the NFL this season.  From a functional offense, scoring around 20 points a game to 3 when it counted.  We are -5 turnovers on the season.  Outside of the obvious Rico Dowdle - Bryce Young, Jimmy Horn, and Travis Etienne are all statistically better rushers right now than Chuba, and yet, we are forcing Chuba touches.  Rico only started two weeks and is still our top rusher for the season.  That forcing Chuba the ball poo might’ve worked when we had no other options, but it literally is destroying the offense now and yet, he keeps doing it.  This insistence of square peg, round hole football is all coaching, and it is absolutely demoralizing.  We show zero consistency with any and everything, and that falls directly at the coach’s feet. Seeing all of this following the few weeks where it appeared the team was picking up some semblance of identity and momentum, and then to lose in such a fashion to where those staples we had begun to believe in were proven to be mirages is beyond discouraging.  Don’t get me wrong, I didn’t expect to beat the Bills.  I did expect to be competitive and still excel at the things we appeared to be making our calling cards.  From the best rushing team for two straight weeks to pedestrian.  From stopping the run and playing smash mouth football to getting blown out at him with opposing players averaging 12 yards per carry and receivers running wide butt naked open.  There is no consistency or leadership on this staff.  Period.  Yesterday’s loss brings us right back to the sobering reality that we still don’t have a head coach and all the problems rife within the Tepper Era.  
×
×
  • Create New...