choose 5 WRs, 3 TEs, 3 RBs, 2 FBs....

[NMFan]

Where does Charly Martin fit into the grand scheme of things? Will the Panthers keep him. He has already proven to be valuable on ST. He has played in a similar system already as he was first signed by SD? Thoughts?

[Guild]

Can't fit him on the team.

[KillerKat]

that makes more sense.... in that case i say Pilares gets the 6th

Exactly. Pilares is not going to get cut. When was the last time Hurney cut a 5th round pick in his rookie year?

[rayzor]

I think if we're gonna have a 2nd FB, Hartsock will fit in as the 3rd TE and backup FB anyway, leaving 1 spot open which I believe will be for a 6th WR.

what about barnidge?

Where does Charly Martin fit into the grand scheme of things? Will the Panthers keep him. He has already proven to be valuable on ST. He has played in a similar system already as he was first signed by SD? Thoughts?

he won't fit. he won't be a panther. too many strong players ahead of him.

[rayzor]

Exactly. Pilares is not going to get cut. When was the last time Hurney cut a 5th round pick in his rookie year?

he'd be moving to the practice squad.

[KillerKat]

what about barnidge?

he won't fit. he won't be a panther. too many strong players ahead of him.

guess he'll be cut in that situation

[KillerKat]

he'd be moving to the practice squad.

but you have to cut him first in order to do that and we won't. plus, that's too risky.

[Guild]

Rayzor you no respond to me because you agree yes?

[rayzor]

guess he'll be cut in that situation

so we'd be better off with some unproven 5th round rookie WR like pilares than a guy we know can play solid ball as a TE receiver and on special teams?

[pantherclaw]

Smith, Gettis, Lafell, Edwards, Naanee

Shockey, Olsen, Barnidge

Williams, Stewart, Goodson

Fiametta, Hartsock

Pilares to the PS.

No room for Sutton if Hartsock is required.

barnidge is good on special teams also. So i see it as..

Smith, Gettis, Lafell, Edwards, Naanee

Olsen, Shockey, Hartsock

Williams, Stewart, Goodson

Fiametta, Sutton

[rayzor]

barnidge is good on special teams also. So i see it as..

Smith, Gettis, Lafell, Edwards, Naanee

Olsen, Shockey, Hartsock

Williams, Stewart, Goodson

Fiametta, Sutton

you left out barnidge. not sure if you were meaning to.

[Guild]

you left out barnidge. not sure if you were meaning to.

He is listed at LS and plays TE behind Olsen in a similar role.

That's the only way I can see the chart working now anyway.

[rayzor]

Rayzor you no respond to me because you agree yes?

i'm not sure which post you are talking about, but i have agreed with everything you've said in this thread...yes.:D

[rayzor]

He is listed at LS and plays TE behind Olsen in a similar role.

That's the only way I can see the chart working now anyway.

yeah, he'd have to be there in a dual role of TE and LS, but then we'd lose out on jensen who is a very solid LS guy. barney would be just learning the job. not sure i feel safe with that.