Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Panthers Free agents signed over the years....


Gscottnc5

Recommended Posts

Thought this would be kind of fun. Lets list any Free Agent signings that the Panthers have made since their inception. Also list whether they were a bust or actually were a good signing

I start with Kevin Greene. One of my all time favorite players. He played crazy. If Peppers had his intensity, Pepps would be unstoppable. Definitley not a bust

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You guys do realize that all free agent history is available via the Panthers website, right?

http://www.panthers.com/Team/Default.aspx?id=802

Oh well, I'll bite.

Those that I consider good or solid acquisitions:

John Kasay

Sam Mills

Frank Reich

Steve Beuerlein

Kevin Greene

Wesley Walls

Brentson Buckner

Jake Delhomme

Ricky Prohel (one of my favs. Wish we had him earlier in his career)

Ken Lucas (he was awesome his first/second season with the Panthers)

Maake Kemoeatu

Damione Lewis (with Maake, made an awesome run-stuffing line)

Interesting picks

Steve Bono (can't believe we actually signed the guy that backed up many other franchise QB's. lol)

Tyler Brayton (yet to be seen if he'll grow)

Keydrick Vincent (looks to be a fantastic signing)

The funny thing is that if you look at the players the Panthers let walk in free agency, none of them really panned out in their next team. Only a few either maintained or expanded their stats (Joe Nedney is still a very solid kicker for the niners, Ricky Manning Jr. had a good 2005 season with the Bears, Will Witherspoon had two great seasons with the Rams after leaving Carolina, Marlon McCree played two good years with the Chargers.)

Seems like the Panthers know what players to let go. No huge losses.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you think that Jake Delhomme is "arguable" as to him being a bust or not your nuts. David Carr are Keyshawn Johnson bust. Someone who keeps you competitive for 5 years and has one bad night does not make him a bust.

Jeff Lewis was a bust

DJ Hackett was a bust

Justin Hartwig was a bust

Sean Gilbert was a fat bust

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you think that Jake Delhomme is "arguable" as to him being a bust or not your nuts. David Carr are Keyshawn Johnson bust. Someone who keeps you competitive for 5 years and has one bad night does not make him a bust.

Jeff Lewis was a bust

DJ Hackett was a bust

Justin Hartwig was a bust

Sean Gilbert was a fat bust

Sean Gilbert was not a bust. If you look at his numbers for those first few years as a Panther, they compare well to the top DTs at the time. They actually are as good as Hayneworth last year, Jenkins, Sapp, many others. The front office was the bust by not working the deal to lessen the franchise player hit before making the offer to him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • That is just Panthers history pain speaking.
    • From what I gather, sure it allows you more room in that you can manipulate the cap more due to smaller prorated amounts to fit salaries in, but for cap purposes, you're still on the hook for the money at the end of the day.    "ChatGPT You said: What are the advantages for NFL teams to sign larger signing bonuses? ChatGPT said: NFL teams often use large signing bonuses as a strategic tool in contracts. While they cost real cash up front, they offer several advantages, especially when it comes to salary cap management, player retention, and negotiation leverage. Here's a breakdown of the benefits: ✅ 1. Salary Cap Flexibility Signing bonuses are prorated over the life of the contract (up to 5 years) for salary cap purposes. This allows teams to spread out the cap hit, even if the player receives the money immediately. Example: A $20M signing bonus on a 4-year deal counts only $5M/year against the cap. ✅ 2. Attracting Top Talent Players love signing bonuses because they're guaranteed money paid up front. Offering a bigger signing bonus can sweeten the deal without inflating yearly salaries. ✅ 3. Front-Loading Real Cash, Not Cap Teams with strong cash flow can pay big bonuses now while minimizing the immediate cap hit. Useful for teams trying to build around rookie QB contracts or with flexible cash budgets. ✅ 4. Locking in Key Players Larger bonuses make it harder for a player to be released early due to dead cap consequences. This can create more job security for the player and roster continuity for the team. ✅ 5. Leverage in Restructures Big signing bonuses create future cap hits via proration. Teams can later restructure deals (e.g., convert salary to bonus) to create even more cap space. ✅ 6. Competitive Edge In free agency, a team offering more guaranteed cash up front often wins the bidding war, even if the total contract value is lower than another team's. ⚠️ Key Caveat: Large signing bonuses increase dead cap risk if the player is cut or traded early."   I think that roster bonuses can be a useful tool if you're trying to keep players in by manipulating numbers and spreading the hit over time, but I don't think that it's something that you want to use unless it's "necessary." I don't know that you want to get into signing rookies on roster bonuses, as the bust rate is relatively high.    
    • not even if that team in New Orleans disbands before the first game.  Saw one 2026 mock that had them drafting first next year.  
×
×
  • Create New...