Is Drew Brees a Hall of Famer?

[Cat'sGrowl]

If Brees wins another SB ,which is entirely possible, he will pull ahead of all those save for Brady. Championships matter.

Championship count doesn't determine the mark a player leaves on history. Bree's has a rather small footprint on it. Even if he acquires more championships, to put him in the same breathe as the players listed above is the most absurd thing I have ever heard.

The mark he leaves should he enter the Hall will put him in the same class as Fouts, Bradshaw, Aikman. If, he enters to begin with.

[Saint J]

Championship count doesn't determine the mark a player leaves on history.

dick pics and being an asshole isn't much of a mark. Favre never fieled consistently dominant offense like Manning, Brady, and now Brees are doing.

[Cat'sGrowl]

dick pics and being an asshole isn't much of a mark. Favre never fieled consistently dominant offense like Manning, Brady, and now Brees are doing.

While I was speaking more to Manning and Brady anyways, Favre also has dibs on almost every major passing record in the game, plus the consecutive game streak and all the other pretty little details.

[Saint J]

While I was speaking more to Manning and Brady anyways, Favre also has dibs on almost every major passing record in the game, plus the consecutive game streak and all the other pretty little details.

he played for what, 15, 16 years? Manning and Brees may pass him up title wise, Brady already has and all three are better numbers wise when we look at their primes. brett favre will be the guy our kids will want to myth bust on message boards in 30-40 years with stats and facts.

[JawnyBlaze]

Brees will get in, maybe not first or even second ballot, but it won't take long. The whole "took the downtrodden Katrina abused bag-over-the-head Saints team to Super Bowl champs within a few years" story will ensure his selection.

[JawnyBlaze]

I'd say Brees is definitely better than Warner, and will probably get in quicker after retirement than Warner. Favre, Manning, and Brady will get in quicker than Brees though. All three of those are first ballot locks.

[JawnyBlaze]

Eh, I think Brees is a 2-5 ballot entry, where McNabb might never get in. He's been solid, but "Reid system QBs" blahblahblah. McNabb's had an ok career. I'll never forgive him for pissing away a golden opportunity to put the brakes on the "Patriot Dynasty".

[thefuzz]

Probably, but not first ballot.

[blackcatgrowl]

I'll never forgive him for pissing away a golden opportunity to put the brakes on the "Patriot Dynasty".

Yeah. If Philly fans weren't generally such douchebags, I'd have been really upset they lost that Super Bowl

If I ever meet Eli Manning, I'm going to tell him he is one of my heros of Football for making 19-0 become 18-1.

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

Yeah. If Philly fans weren't generally such douchebags, I'd have been really upset they lost that Super Bowl

If I ever meet Eli Manning, I'm going to tell him he is one of my heros of Football for making 19-0 become 18-1.

Probably the only thing nice i'd say about Eli :D

[Cat'sGrowl]

McNabb won't sniff the Hall. Not with the way his career is ending.

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

I dont know that the HoF committee puts too much weight in the final years of a candidates that "age out" of the league. I mean I'm sure Joe Montana's final 9-6 campaign or Emmit Smith's 1100 yards over his final two years had any bearing on they appointment.

Yes but Joe Montana was the dominant player of his era and has 4 rings. Smith is the all time leading rusher and has 3.

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

Right and they were first ballot material. I'm not putting Donovan up there with them, I'm just saying that I think the HoF voters probably don't hold that stuff against an otherwise deserving candidate.

Ahh misunderstood you. I think McNabb has had an underrated career tbh. 28 Rushing TDs career 2-1 TD/INT ratio which only i think Brady/Manning have better.

[blackcatgrowl]

Ahh misunderstood you. I think McNabb has had an underrated career tbh. 28 Rushing TDs career 2-1 TD/INT ratio which only i think Brady/Manning have better.

Since there is no criteria for having Super Bowl victories to enter the HoF, you have a very valid point.