ESPN Rank 'Em NFL ROY

[Cat]

Cam is the best rookie by far, it's not even a conversation to have. Great rookie class so far.

[TheOracle]

Your Rankings

1.Cam Newton

2.A.J. Green

3.Aldon Smith

4.Von Miller

5.Andy Dalton

6.Patrick Peterson

7.Julio Jones

8.Torrey Smith

9.J.J. Watt

10.Tyron Smith

[TheOracle]

1.Cam Newton

2.Von Miller

3.Aldon Smith

4.Andy Dalton

5.Patrick Peterson

6.A.J. Green

7.Julio Jones

8.J.J. Watt

9.Torrey Smith

10.Tyron Smith

How can Dalton be better than Green, when Green has made Dalton look good more than Dalton has made Green look good?

[Cat'sGrowl]

Grits has turned into a more pathetic version of PFFL.

[Redskinny]

Please Dalton is the key to the whole teams success. Without his skill as a passer Green would be running routes and not have balls thrown in his direction...Much like Steve Smith from last season.

[NCstoner420]

How can Dalton be better than Green, when Green has made Dalton look good more than Dalton has made Green look good?

Because it is my list so that is why. Wide Receiver is an easier position to come in and make an impact as a rookie but Dalton has played really good this year and if Newton had not played he would be the unanimous rookie of the year.

[Panthercougar68]

Please Dalton is the key to the whole teams success. Without his skill as a passer Green would be running routes and not have balls thrown in his direction...Much like Steve Smith from last season.

I can think of plenty of heaves by Dalton that if not thrown to Green they wouldn't be caught.

That one in the first Pittsburgh game where Dalton chucked it up to a double covered Green...Green made that play like many others through the season.

[Munch4455]

Is demarco murray not on the list? Cowboys rb, I think thats his name.

[rainwater]

So ESPN is making up awards now? At least have a offensive and defensive vote to match reality.

[Panthercougar68]

Is demarco murray not on the list? Cowboys rb, I think thats his name.

He was too late to the show since he only played 5 games this season. It doesn't help that he's on IR now too.

Plus after having those first explosive games he dropped of A LOT in his last few games.

[tiger7_88]

Grits has turned into a more pathetic version of PFFL.

No, I'm afraid he has about 100 more alts to go before he's that pathetic.

[PantherFanOne]

Even though Cam presently has a good lead we all need to vote for him several times.

[Miguel O'Hara]

I put Cam at number one(i mean honestly, why would you put him lower) then just closed my eyes and picked the rest. Cam is so far and beyond everyone else they didn't really deserve major attention. Its Cam Newton at one, then everyone else, waaaaaaay down the list at 2.

[Get_on_my_horse]

I put Dalton at one because he's had less to work with and has his team on the up swing and a shot at the playoffs. Cinci was picked to have one of the worst records in football and he changed the direction of the franchise and that is hard to do especially as a 2nd round pick.