Newton or Vick?

[rayzor]

Considering how much Vick gets injured as he attempts his dual threats, I'd say Cam.

Damn, the guy gets injured even while sitting in the pocket. Like isn't there penalties or something for ish like that...SMH

his injuries come more when he's in the pocket. that's when any QB is the most prone. they are safer running out of it because they actually have some control over what happens to them. inside the pocket they have their blind side to worry about and not just rushers coming in, but their own linemen getting pushed back or falling into them.

[Mr. Scot]

Newton is the quarterback Michael Vick wishes he could be.

[Gazi]

you could of said all of that in one post

for sure. he's got the MSN syndrome.

[Davidson Deac II]

Cam is better "built" to run. Hes more durable and bigger than vick by a lot. But i think vick is a faster runner

Agreed. Vick is probably the quickest accelerating and shifting qb in the history of the NFL, although Cam and Vick are probably about equal in a straight line. But Cam is bigger and stronger. And a much better passer.

[Disinfranchised]

Did you get any neg rep for this Big s17? There is no comparison. Newton is what Vick wanted to be, but never will. Vick is scuzzyslime. Newton is an all american good person. Vick sucks as a human being. Nfl records will show Newton to be a much , much better passer.

[redbuddha]

No Sammy Baugh was. Passing, running, Played safety(let the league in INTs one season) and also was one of the best punters ever.

Wouldn't that make him a quadruple threat?

Besides Cam is a Triple threat, he has 27 receiving yards.

[BigSyke]

no, im saying who had the better SEASON. not who is better. vick did have great numbers and a better td ratio than newton last season but newton is a rookie. thats all im saying.

people compare The Golden Calf of Bristol to newton all the time, i compared him to someone that actually had a great SEASON as a dual qb.

[bleys]

Post farming bro. 5x more posts is 5x more chance for swag or Pi, right?

:lol:

[jb_online]

Vick is a wussy. Cam is not, he's like the Anti-Vick... all the strengths, none of the weaknesses (so far). And I'd say that if Cam was in Cincinnati or Buffalo or where ever. Vick has a lot of guys around him who make him better. Cam has a lot of guys around him who CAM makes better.