So Right now...Peyton or Eli?

[Dpantherman]

I've defended Eli all season long, and yes he had some up and down games, but this has clearly been the best season of his career. But need to build a super bowl team for 1 year, who do you take?

[Cam's New Arm]

Eli is only 2/3 of the QB that Peyton was

[tarheelpride]

Right now, currently??? Give me Eli.

If you asked last year or even a few weeks ago, I'd say Peyton.

[Keith Moons Liver]

if they both get to throw to hakeem nicks? peyton

[Dpantherman]

Eli is only 2/3 of the QB that Peyton was

In the postseason

Peyton: 435/692 63% 28tds 19ints 87.6 rtg W/L- 9/10

Eli: 157/258 61% 14tds 8ints 90.4 rtg W/L 6/3

BTW, Peyton was 3-6 in his first 9 playoff games.

[Dpantherman]

if they both get to throw to hakeem nicks? peyton

Peyton had Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, AND Dallas Clark. try again.

[Keith Moons Liver]

Peyton had Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, AND Dallas Clark. try again.

i see a list of a bunch of guys much worse than nicks

[Dpantherman]

Oh please with the notion that Peyton's weapons were worse. That argument is poo with anyone that knows anything about football.

[Davidson Deac II]

Peyton in his prime vs Eli in his prime.

Thats a no brainer, peyton.

Both have good receivers, but the Giants have a much better running game and defense for the last few years.

Right now though, well since Peyton might never play again, that one is easy. :)

[Kevin Greene]

The way Eli and the Giant D is playing I'm gong to be picking #32 in this years Huddle draft. :lol:

[Keith Moons Liver]

Oh please with the notion that Peyton's weapons were worse. That argument is poo with anyone that knows anything about football.

defense is a weapon far more important than any individual receiver, and the colts D is and has been awful

harrison, wayne etc. are/were good receivers with a great QB

nicks is a great receiver with a good QB

[Dpantherman]

Peyton in his prime vs Eli in his prime.

Thats a no brainer, peyton.

Both have good receivers, but the Giants have a much better running game and defense for the last few years.

Right now though, well since Peyton might never play again, that one is easy. :)

I think its a no brainer in the regular season. First 9 games head to head in the playoffs. Theres a legit argument.

Peyton is in the convo for greatest regular season QB ever.

[footballisasport]

Eli is only 2/3 of the QB that Peyton was

You have got to realize, unlike Peyton, who was given free reign to mold a team the way he wanted. Eli is part of a franchise with some history. Unlike his brother, Eli has to be part of that legacy and not try to re-invent the wheel with the Giants.

I always felt Eli was equal to his brother but it's clear who the media choose and Eli had to play second fiddle.

[Dpantherman]

defense is a weapon far more important than any individual receiver, and the colts D is and has been awful

harrison, wayne etc. are/were good receivers with a great QB

nicks is a great receiver with a good QB

Im talking about two QBs head to head, not the teams.

And there is no way you can just say Harrison, Wayne, and Clark were just some guys and Peyton made them great. Did Joe Montana make Jerry Rice great? Did Aikman make Irvin?

You know it is possible to have a great receiver and a great QB right?