Manning's mobility Vs. Newton's mobility

[TonyN]

Whose would you rather have???

Several of Carolina's sacks today were inexcusable. Including the saftey.

QB has to make a read and get rid of the football...or slide in the pocket and escape the pressure....

Anything except stand like a statue in the pocket for 4 to 5 seconds while pressure comes right up the middle...

Newton freezes...Newton freezes a lot....He has to pull the trigger...It is almost like he does not have the confidence to throw the ball into tight coverage...

[YoungPanthers89]

So why hasnt this grits alt been banned yet?

[megadeth078]

not moving in the pocket after only 2 seconds =/= statue

[Rubi]

He's needs a true off. Play caller and better coaching. Gotta break bad habits

[BBQ&Beer]

Cam's mobility with Manning's experience.

[the butch]

that's what running the read option for a year and not developing your qb will do for you. we started out this year doing the same thing. CAM NEWTON IS IN HIS SECOND YEAR IN THE LEAGUE. you have to develop your qb. stop trying to implement a gimmick offense.

[Salvo]

Peyton moves around with precision. Cam's a deer caught in the headlights and when he finally feels the heat, he tries to escape like a gaggling goose. He lacks the confidence and swag that he had last year to step into the pocket and deliver with conviction.

[beastson]

Come on people, I know things are bad but we have to do better than this

Maybe this is good for Cam. Lower expectations for next year for him. His expectations are wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy too high

Comparing him to Manning, who's been the league... idk over 15 years

[CRA]

Manning is much better today than he was at this point in time n Newton's career. Silly to ask if you would rather have the game experience and knowledge of one of the greatest QBs to ever play the game vs. what a current inexperienced 2 nd year player has......

......one do many examples of how flawed people's logic is when looking at Newton.

Also, G play is huge in regards to what we are talking about. Manning experts a pocket to step into....Newton takes a snap and wonders each play where the pressure will come from.

[bigmanstew]

Manning has flawless mechanics in the pocket and a brilliant level of pocket presence. He doesn't half of Newton's athletic ability, but I'm not sure Newton has half of Manning's ability in the pocket either.

[Originalman]

Manning also has an OL. Look how clean his pocket was most of the time and there was never push up the middle so he could always step up.

[usmcpanthers]

Peyton has 2 years left MAXX. Cam is the future, we just have to get a real coaching staff to groom him. Alex Smith is a great example.