Setting aside the "Newton vs Luck" stuff...

[Jackofalltrades]

It's a good story, but Luck is taking some of the spotlight off some of the more deserving guys.

I want to see the Colts win a game and the Falcons go one and done.

[Mr. Scot]

It's a good story, but Luck is taking some of the spotlight off some of the more deserving guys.

I want to see the Colts win a game and the Falcons go one and done.

Part two of that wish is more likely to happen than part one.

[Kakarot]

Russel Wilson or RG3 deserve rookie of the year. They have truly had outstanding seasons.

[Mr. Scot]

Russel Wilson or RG3 deserve rookie of the year. They have truly had outstanding seasons.

You could make an argument, for certain.

With that said, given the emotion surrounding the Colts season and the hype surrounding Andrew Luck, don't be surprised if he wins it.

Honestly, I could live with any of those three getting the nod.

[hepcat]

To say the 2012 Colts overachieved is an understatement. They are built like the 2010 KC Chiefs or the '08 Miami Dolphins so I expect a big decline in 2013.

[Boltergeist]

Part two of that wish is more likely to happen than part one.

I think it's the other way around. Baltimore is so sketch these days, it wouldn't surprise me to see Indy go in there and win.

[Mr. Scot]

To say the 2012 Colts overachieved is an understatement. They are built like the 2010 KC Chiefs or the '08 Miami Dolphins so I expect a big decline in 2013.

Be kind of a downer if the Colts tanked after Pagano came back full time.

However, knowing the way the world works, that's probably what'll happen.

[Jackofalltrades]

Part two of that wish is more likely to happen than part one.

That would be just fine with me.

[Jackofalltrades]

Be kind of a downer if the Colts tanked after Pagano came back full time.

However, knowing the way the world works, that's probably what'll happen.

Well, it's going to be very emtional and which way they channel that will determine how it works out in the end.

[Jackofalltrades]

You could make an argument, for certain.

With that said, given the emotion surrounding the Colts season and the hype surrounding Andrew Luck, don't be surprised if he wins it.

Honestly, I could live with any of those three getting the nod.

If I had to list my OROY's it would be

1. Wilson

2. Griffin

3. Doug Martin

4. Andrew Luck

[Mr. Scot]

Realistically, Martin has no shot (deserving or not).

[Guest Slenderman]

Morris>Martin

[Brooklyn Bully]

Luck vs Cam is the new Peyton vs Brady. We should appreciate this, not tear them down.

Are you new here? Luck could've thrown for 6000 yds and they could've played the Packers every game, and RGIII could have played blind with a broken femur while the Skins played the Pats every game and this retarded board will still belittle anything not slurping the sack that is Cam and the fact we could easily have won 11 games this year.

Worst homers in the NFL, folks. Right here.

[Jackofalltrades]

Realistically, Martin has no shot (deserving or not).

Oh I agree, but he's earned the recognition he does get.