Grade the Panthers Day 3 and Overall Draft Picks

[SZ James (banned)]

Um he was drafted in the 4th round. Therefore its not speculation he had a 4th round grade by some team.

Do you live in some kind of parallel universe where reaching for picks holds no consequence?

How did you feel about the EJ Manuel pick? The bills scouts are must be geniuses since there was probably like five QBs projected ahead of him according to those ignorant experts at walterfootball.

[tiger7_88]

How did you feel about the EJ Manuel pick? The bills scouts are must be geniuses since there was probably like five QBs projected ahead of him according to those ignorant experts at walterfootball.

EJ Manuel was the most Cam/RG3/Kaep/Wilson-capable pick of all the QB candidates available and had a 1st-2nd round grade.

The Buffalo Bills saw the future of NFL QBing and chose to ride the train instead of getting run over by it.

[SZ James (banned)]

EJ Manuel was the most Cam/RG3/Kaep/Wilson-capable pick of all the QB candidates available and had a 1st-2nd round grade.

The Buffalo Bills saw the future of NFL QBing and chose to ride the train instead of getting run over by it.

at least you seem consistant on your, uh, "analysis"

wow

[Happy Panther]

Yeah, because the other OG prospects were little fuggers and Kugbila stood out. :rolleyes:

Well he does have an inch and a few pounds over what I think would be the average guy.

http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/prospectrankings/2013/OG

[Dash Global]

Do you live in some kind of parallel universe where reaching for picks holds no consequence?

How did you feel about the EJ Manuel pick? The bills scouts are must be geniuses since there was probably like five QBs projected ahead of him according to those ignorant experts at walterfootball.

How was he a reach? Let me guess, bc CBS or Walters said he was x grade?!?! lmao

Let me tell you why he was not a reach.

Great size, frame, and measurables.

Athletic

Quick

Gave up zero - little sacks and hurries

[tiger7_88]

at least you seem consistant on your, uh, "analysis"

wow

I actually like to be excited about Panther players until I'm given good reason not to be.

I like to point out the positives and why they will succeed rather than negatives and why they will fail.

Its called "being a fan".

[Happy Panther]

LMAO I didnt think you would be able to answer that.

I didn't answer it because you didn't ask a question. Rather you listed a bunch of Harry Reid-esque strawmen and circular logic points that support your argument and then asked me to prove something. And you used the "Enlighten me?" phrase which is just annoying

I try to disengage with this type of juvenile stuff.

I do hope he succeeds but I just don't see it. Good day.

[Dash Global]

I didn't answer it because you didn't ask a question. Rather you listed a bunch of Harry Reid-esque strawmen and circular logic points that support your argument and then asked me to prove something. And you used the "Enlighten me?" phrase which is just annoying

I try to disengage with this type of juvenile stuff.

I do hope he succeeds but I just don't see it. Good day.

I asked you to explain why he was not an SEC caliber player / recruit. I threw in the other stuff to help you give your answer as that is the stuff defines a OL talent / potential / star rating. You didnt answer it because you cant answer it without looking stupid.

How is he not SEC caliber? If he was a 3-5 star prospect than he was SEC/D1 level talent.

What is he lacking? Size? Athleticism? Speed / Quickness? Power? Blocking Skills?

[SZ James (banned)]

How was he a reach? Let me guess, bc CBS or Walters said he was x grade?!?! lmao

Let me tell you why he was not a reach.

Great size, frame, and measurables.

Athletic

Quick

Gave up zero - little sacks and hurries

Geat analysis bro I bet you didn't copy and paste that from a scouting site and I bet you watched the guard play in every Valdosa State game. :lol:

Get out

[SZ James (banned)]

I actually like to be excited about Panther players until I'm given good reason not to be.

I like to point out the positives and why they will succeed rather than negatives and why they will fail.

Its called "being a fan".

There's fandom and then there's fandumb

[Dash Global]

Geat analysis bro I bet you didn't copy and paste that from a scouting site and I bet you watched the guard play in every Valdosa State game. :lol:

Get out

You can get all that from the combine measurements and tests, along with his stats from past season.

Dont need to read any scouting report.

[tiger7_88]

There's fandom and then there's fandumb

I prefer to label it as "fans" and "menstruating whiners".

[SZ James (banned)]

Got that from Gettleman. Which Ill take over posters on the huddle.

You are free to use fallacious arguments as you wish

nice edit, wanker

[The Huddler]

You have to understand that SEC schools "expressed interest." Doesn't mean they were handing him scholarships or that he is an SEC caliber G. (Hint: he isn't)

There are tons of schools that can get past academics if he was that talented. (Hint: He wasn't)

Also understand how bad the Gulf South Conference is.

He is a massive guy with 7th round potential. I wouldn't make any bets on his career.

I feel ya man. I see both sides of the story. i think he was a reach too but im excited about his potential now that we have him