Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Game of Thrones - Differences in the show and the books so far


Bronn

Recommended Posts

Okay this thread stems from one of the other GOT threads. I don't want to get too spoilery here. If you want to spoil things, go to the book thread.

I would like to use this thread to point out any major plot deviations from the books to the show, in order to shine light on why book readers can be seemingly whiny about the changes at times. Also, there might be some show-only folks that are considering the books, or don't want to read them at all, and just want more info.

I'll try to update this as I think of differences, and encourage you all to do so as well.

To start with, I think the biggest changes are the omission of some characters. I won't say much about these characters other than who they are, in hopes that maybe the show will tackle them in the future.

Off the top of my head, you have Theon's uncles, Euron, Victarion, and Aeron. They all have roles that I feel like the show will get to next season, at least partially.

Other missing characters include: Arianne Martell (Doran's daughter), Coldhands (appears to be an intelligent wight, or something, riding an elk that runs into Bran and co. and assists them in getting to the cave), Lady Stoneheart (I am torn whether or not to say who/what she is due to the potential that the show breaks down and includes her), Strong Belwas (a guy that was helping Barristan in his journey to Dany, and who joined Dany's council after), Jeyne Poole (Sansa's childhood friend we saw in season one, but she has a bigger part in the books (namely acting as a fake Arya in Sansa's role this past season)), Willas and Garlan Tyrell (older brothers to Margaery and Loras), Val (Mance Rayder's wife and child bearer) and a slew of other players in the North and South, heads of smaller houses, etc.

Some characters have had different outcomes or roles on the show. The biggest of these were Robb's wife (still alive in the books, and some even think her family helped plan the Red Wedding, named Jeyne Westerling in the books), Sansa (playing the role of Fake Arya (Jeyne Poole) this past season), Bronn (kind of happy with Lollys in the books, it seems... he has taken on an advanced role in the show), Tyrion (hasn't met Dany face to face in the books), Barristan Selmy (still alive in the books), Stannis (still alive in the books (maybe in the show?)), Brienne (most of her stuff this season and last is brand new material), etc.

I'm sure I am forgetting a lot of stuff on the character differences front, but those are the first I notice.

For the most part, a lot of the plotting seems the same. Hardhome didn't really happen like it did on the show. Jon SENT Stannis' boats, and they came back with tales of terrible things, sicknesses, etc. and lost some ships on the way. Sam got sent away to Oldtown with Gilly, a swapped baby (Mance Rayder's child), and Maester Aemon (who dies on the boat trip) before the events of the finale. Wun Wun the giant causes a distraction at the wall by literally ripping apart a knight, which is when For The Watch happens in the books (everyone is lost in the chaos of what Wun Wun is doing)...

I will add more as I think of them... Remember not to get too spoilery...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Loras Tyrell is a big change that bugs me. In the books he was so in love with Renly that he never took another lover. Show turned him into a slut who got over Renly real quick. Also, he was the 3rd son, not the heir, and joined the Kingsguard.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Agree totally on Loras...

Another big difference I just thought of was the difference in the amount of prophecy. In the books, there is tons. It opens the door to a lot of the theories we always bring up.

Also, in the books, Arya and Jon have both had dreams where one could assume they are unknowingly warging into their dire wolves. Neither has explored it beyond having the few dreams, however.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Loras Tyrell is a big change that bugs me. In the books he was so in love with Renly that he never took another lover. Show turned him into a slut who got over Renly real quick. Also, he was the 3rd son, not the heir, and joined the Kingsguard.

​I agree. It's one of the things I'm most disappointed with in the show. His line in the book about once the sun goes down no candle can replace it was a great line. They cheapened him and Renly and I can't figure out why. I feel like turning him into a slut didn't add anything great to the show besides implicating him for the high sparrow.

 

I also wish they didn't get rid of Garlan and Willis Tyrell, but I can understand why they didn't want to add too many characters.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I started off with the show then went to the books... Then back to the show when I knew all the spoilers..( Joffrey, the fight between the mountain and the Red Vyper) . At the end of one of the books .. Someone that I'll keep a nameless female character is alive again or at least upright at a river. Along with the OP's posts about Theon's family. Can anyone shed any light ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One thing that I definitely liked better in the show than the books was the ages of the kids.  I just got weirded out thinking about Tyrion marrying a 12 year old girl.  Not that 16 makes it a whole lot better...

Yeah not to mention Dany being 13 when Daario "took her in every way a man could take a woman."

I can think of a lot of ways.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • TAMU had such a weird draft. Usually you'd be bragging your ass off about three DL drafted in the top two rounds except that the narrative around all three was about how badly they were misused by TAMU. LOL
    • Many Panthers fans are already excited about second-round selection Nic Scourton for a variety of reasons including but not limited to: the Panthers needed to recharge the position group, Scourton had a late first-round grade according to many (including the Panthers), and he fit this season's modus operandi of stopping the run now and forever. However, Scourton was seen early on as one of the top-3 EDGE guys in this class but fell due to not having quite the season at Texas A&M as he did prior at Purdue (his sophomore season). It's been revealed since then a few different things that speak to that dip in production... Texas A&M, for one, requires each player on their line to be able to hold two gaps. This also explains why we saw low production across the board from the other two TA&M prospects but were still being heavily touted. Scourton was also said to have bulked up to 280lbs in order to fulfill this role and noticeably suffered from it. He's expected to play this season with Carolina at 255 - 260 which is very different from most situations. In most situations, teams are wanting players to gain 15 - 30. Since Scourton is going to be playing at his Purdue weight, I thought it would make sense to dive more into that tape. Y'all... we might have gotten something special... Let's take a quick peek at the stats before we start drooling over some highlights. First, a summary of the last two seasons for Scourton: Second, the game splits: The first thing that pops up for me is how Scourton's sack numbers were cut in half his senior year. We've already pointed out issues with scheme that impacted the TA&M linemen from racking up numbers, but seeing the game splits it's clear that Scourton didn't exactly feast on inferior competition while at Purdue. He had two two-sack games (vs. Michigan (2023 - 2024 champs), Indiana) and a 10-tackle game (vs. Nebraska). I also see the 2024 games where he went up against two top-10 tackles (Will Campbell from LSU + Armand Membou from Missouri) that I watched leading up to the draft.  For those who just want a summary: Scourton looked elite at Purdue and is going to be rotating in often during his rookie campaign. I originally had him penciled in as the second-string, strong-side edge defender behind Clowney but I wouldn't be surprised to see the team have him and Pat Jones II moving around when they rotate in in order to find where Nic looks best. Here's a highlight reel to replace that Cialias you lost in your recliner tonight:   For those that want a little more: Below I'll be linking the linking the five games I've mentioned above. If you plan to watch all of them, I highly recommend going in the order listed as that will allow you to see him vs. Campbell and then Membou while dealing with the aforementioned things he dealt with at Texas A&M before seeing him look unstoppable in 2023 when he was allowed to play both at a comfortable weight and in a scheme that didn't require him two cover two gaps nearly every play. vs. Will Campbell (2024) vs. Armand Membou (2024) vs. Nebraska (2023) vs. Michigan (2023)   vs. Indiana (2023)  
    • Yea, i honestly think he had almost as much say as Dan.  One of the main reasons I think that is Eager has said before he was ever with the Panthers, that you trade away picks for a qb and for any other position you do pick swaps, and that's exactly what we did.
×
×
  • Create New...