HYPOTHETICAL Cam Trades Thread

[Mr. Scot]

Just now, SBiii said:

That's it?  No more specifics whatsoever?  Didn't give any details about what his "source" said on how Cam might get out of here? 

Trade?  Cut?  Quit the game?

Nothing? 

What kind of "source" is that?

One who's rarely wrong.

[SBiii]

26 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

One who's rarely wrong.

Too funny....."trust me"....LOL.

Since you are in the Cam is gone camp, what kind of percentages would you put on him possibly returning?  Less that 25%?  Less than 10%?

What say ye? 

 

 

[SBiii]

15 minutes ago, Kinographer said:

Nearly every trusted source of Panthers news has said that Newton is likely gone.

Really?

First question....exactly who are these "trusted sources" you are referencing?  Please list the top-4.

Second, what reason/s they are the citing for Cam's departure?

Can you point to anything specific? 

Anything at all?

[BrizzMachete]

anything less than a first we need to hang up the phone ASAP 

[SBiii]

5 minutes ago, BrizzMachete said:

anything less than a first we need to hang up the phone ASAP 

Do you believe "a first" would be proper compensation for parting ways with Cam Newton?  Is that a fair trade?

[BrizzMachete]

7 minutes ago, SBiii said:

Do you believe "a first" would be proper compensation for parting ways with Cam Newton?  Is that a fair trade?

Yeap can’t do no higher than first round : i rather we keep him but it looks unlikely so yeah a first would be fine by me 

[SBiii]

20 minutes ago, BrizzMachete said:

Yeap can’t do no higher than first round : i rather we keep him but it looks unlikely so yeah a first would be fine by me 

So you believe trading an MVP franchise QB for an unknown 1st rounder is a good deal? 

If so you must believe Cam will never be any good again.  if this is the case why would anyone give us a 1st rounder for him?

[BrizzMachete]

10 minutes ago, SBiii said:

So you believe trading an MVP franchise QB for an unknown 1st rounder is a good deal? 

If so you must believe Cam will never be any good again.  if this is the case why would anyone give us a 1st rounder for him?

I mean dude he been injured the past 3-4 years what you think a team gonna give us 3 first rounders . You acting like cam won mvp last year . I feel your frustration but be reasonable fam lol 

[weyco2000]

On 11/10/2019 at 12:21 PM, gorillamilitia13 said:

Been a Panthers fan my whole life but I'm going where he's going. 

Happy retirement!

[Wire Dawg]

Really it all depends, are you asking right now, without passing a physical and not being cleared to play? 2nd round if the Panthers are lucky or a 3rd round is more realistic. Clearing a physical and paying pre-season and showing he is game ready, then you can ask for a 1st and settle for a second if you have to. The problem is right now he is in that Peyton Manning with the Colts predicament, everyone expects him to come back 100% but what is his 100%? The Superbowl contender? Or someone that can't run with the ball and is trying to be a pocket passer? It all depends where he is. 

[SBiii]

7 hours ago, BrizzMachete said:

I mean dude he been injured the past 3-4 years what you think a team gonna give us 3 first rounders . You acting like cam won mvp last year . I feel your frustration but be reasonable fam lol 

Again, do you believe trading Cam for a single 1st rounder is a good deal?

Put another way, given what we know right now do you believe there's a team out there that would give a 1st rounder for Cam right now?

[SBiii]

4 hours ago, Wire Dawg said:

(i)  Really it all depends, are you asking right now, without passing a physical and not being cleared to play?

(ii)  2nd round if the Panthers are lucky or a 3rd round is more realistic.

(iii)  Clearing a physical and paying pre-season and showing he is game ready, then you can ask for a 1st and settle for a second if you have to.

(i)  Yes.

(ii)  Exactly.

(iii)  So after he shows he's "game ready" and balls out you are going to let him go for an unknown 1st rounder? 

I will guarantee you that if Cam shows he is "game ready" Tepper will not let Hurndog trade him for a single 1st rounder.

A healthy Cam is WAY more valuable than that.

[uncfan888]

8 hours ago, SBiii said:

So you believe trading an MVP franchise QB for an unknown 1st rounder is a good deal? 

If so you must believe Cam will never be any good again.  if this is the case why would anyone give us a 1st rounder for him?

You think about this stuff way too much. 

[Wire Dawg]

2 minutes ago, SBiii said:

(iii)  So after he shows he's "game ready" and balls out you are going to let him go for an unknown 1st rounder?

Humm, good question, yes I would. Go for the complete unknown. Because, if he is balls out "game ready" he is going to want a deal before the pre-season is over. He won't be playing without some sort of ink in place. So, yes, I'd take an unknown before committing to a deal. Sadly, I don't think his body can stand up to the player he wants to be. He wants to be a runner that is the ultimate game changer, and he can do that, but again he will eventually get hurt. I personally wouldn't be willing to take that risk. IF he signs another contract, it will probably be his last NFL deal, so he won't settle for anything less than top 5 QB money if he feels he is 100%.