Rank Panthers all-time top 10 players

[Matt Foley]

Criteria: career accomplishments in black and blue

10. Muhsin Muhammad, WR

9. Dan Morgan, LB

8. Kris Jenkins, DT

7. Jordan Gross, T

6. DeAngelo Williams, RB

5. Michael Bates, KR

4. Wesley Walls, TE

3. John Kasay, K

2. Julius Peppers, DE

1. Steve Smith, WR

[Black]

i would have moose higher

[704Designs]

yep and hate him or not, you gotta put Jake in there.

[KillerKat]

1. Sam Mills

2. John Kasay

3. Moose

4. Smitty

5. Peppers

6. Wesley Walls

7. Kevin Greene

8. DeAngelo

9. Jenkins

10. Minter

[Matt Foley]

Remember...Bates went to like five Pro Bowls

[CRA]

Criteria: career accomplishments in black and blue

10. Muhsin Muhammad, WR

9. Dan Morgan, LB

8. Kris Jenkins, DT

7. Jordan Gross, T

6. DeAngelo Williams, RB

5. Michael Bates, KR

4. Wesley Walls, TE

3. John Kasay, K

2. Julius Peppers, DE

1. Steve Smith, WR

well if career accomplishments is the criteria and not best......

Moose is probably top 4 as he holds all the recieving records in Carolina. Also, I would have to find a way to put Jake somewhere and Minter also. I would probably bump Gross and Morgan out.

[faultlessjoint]

How could you leave out Rucker?

:nono:

[Matt Foley]

Rucker, Minter, Mills, Greene....the Panthers have finally been around long enough that you have to leave off great players on a list like this.

[Sam Mills Fan]

With apologies to Brad Hoover, Michael Bates, DeAngelo Williams, Steve Beuerlein, Dan Morgan, Kevin Greene, Mike Rucker, and Eric Davis...

1. Sam Mills

2. Steve Smith

3. Muhsin Muhammad

4. Wesley Walls

5. Julius Peppers

6. Mike Minter

7. Jon Beason

8. Jake Delhomme

9. Jordan Gross

10. John Kasay

[CRA]

Rucker, Minter, Mills, Greene....the Panthers have finally been around long enough that you have to leave off great players on a list like this.

I don't think there are 10 guys who have done more than Minter in a Panther uniform

[E CaT PanTHer]

10. Jeff Lewis

9. Steve Bono

8. Dameyune Craig

7. Chuck Smith

6. Keary Colbert

5. Chris Weinke

4. Richie Cunningham

3. Randy Fasani

2. Eric Swann

1. Rae Carruth

[PantherDude]

10. Jeff Lewis

9. Steve Bono

8. Dameyune Craig

7. Chuck Smith

6. Keary Colbert

5. Chris Weinke

4. Richie Cunningham

3. Randy Fasani

2. Eric Swann

1. Rae Carruth

You're in the wrong thread, dude. :sifone:

But this is quite a hard one, so I'll give my best here.

1.) Steve Smith

2.) Julius Peppers

3.) Moooooosee!!!!

4.) Kevin Greene

5.) DeAngelo Williams

6.) Jake Delhomme

7.) Stephen Davis

8.) Dan Morgan

9.) Wesley Walls

10.) Sam Mills

[Nytrogen]

I cried when Minter retired.

[Mr ocho nueve]

10) Peppers

9) Mills

8) Mike Rucker

7) Ken Lucas (still wondering why we let him go....)

6) Foster (Dwill will trump him on the list after this year)

5) Hoover

4) Moose

3) Mike Minter

2) Jake Delhomme

1) Steve Smith

this was tough to think about lol so many players to recognize.