Young vs Stroud (1-0)

[FutureDynasty]

1 minute ago, frankw said:

The thing is if you rewind back to April and the weeks before the draft the most toxic people on this board were those who railed against anyone skeptical of Bryce Young.

Yeah there is nothing wrong with us correctly pointing out what we see in Bryce Young. Which is a bad QB that should have never been picked in the first 3 rounds, let alone 1st overall.

[AggieLean]

Stroud was the layup. Stroud was the guy. 
 

It’s unfortunate that Bryce is having to work with Reich and this god awful team, but even without that, I don’t know. I believe Stroud would look a little better under this regime.

Anyways, @CPF4LIFE you’ve been on the money since the start of the offseason, and didn’t waiver like a lot of us did. A lot of us switched to Bryce when it was apparent the panthers were going to make him the pick. You’ve been right.

[mrcompletely11]

Just now, AggieLean said:

Stroud was the layup. Stroud was the guy. 
 

It’s unfortunate that Bryce is having to work with Reich and this god awful team, but even without that, I don’t know. I believe Stroud would look a little better under this regime.

Anyways, @CPF4LIFE you’ve been on the money since the start of the offseason, and didn’t waiver like a lot of us did. A lot of us switched to Bryce when it was apparent the panthers were going to make him the pick. You’ve been right.

Stroud had the highest floor and highest ceiling, anyone with a brain could see that

[frankw]

What really stings is the former Panthers who all went to bat for Bryce Young and didn't for one moment say hey maybe we should pause for a sec and take another look at CJ Stroud.

[CPF4LIFE]

4 hours ago, AggieLean said:

Stroud was the layup. Stroud was the guy. 
 

It’s unfortunate that Bryce is having to work with Reich and this god awful team, but even without that, I don’t know. I believe Stroud would look a little better under this regime.

Anyways, @CPF4LIFE you’ve been on the money since the start of the offseason, and didn’t waiver like a lot of us did. A lot of us switched to Bryce when it was apparent the panthers were going to make him the pick. You’ve been right.

I appreciate that brother. The crazy thing is, in situations like this i dont enjoy being right. I mean significant bad decisions just set the team back and i really want to win. Thats all at the end of the day, and its not gonna happen if you dont get it right at QB. For people that call it hate, i really did go back and watch a lot of tape to try to convince myself on bryce and i just didnt see it. It has nothing to do with it personally, i didnt see an elite nfl player. I kept my eye on stroud for the last 2 years, watched an insane amount throws/games and it was just clear as day to me the high level of talent i was watching. I thought Georgia game cemented it, but the media push for bryce just got so crazy and i had to come to terms we was bout to make a bad decision and i wasn't gonna change my mindset as a fan all because the team did something stupid. I never thought it was right so why should i support it? I will be happy when the experiment is over. 

[CPF4LIFE]

And yes, its still a possibility bryce could prove me wrong...but its just crazy low chances and faith right now. 

[GhostWhispah]

On 11/10/2023 at 5:00 AM, FutureDynasty said:

Yeah there is nothing wrong with us correctly pointing out what we see in Bryce Young. Which is a bad QB that should have never been picked in the first 3 rounds, let alone 1st overall.

So you come to the conclusion that without playmakers, Bryce cannot succeed but than assumed CJ can? 

You obviously don't get it which is sad my friend