Sutton or Goodson?...

[KillerKat]

With the strong possibility of us keeping 2 FBs on the roster, IF it came down to the FO having to choose between Goodson and Sutton who do you think they would choose?

IMO, even though there's room to keep both, I think they would choose Goodson if they chose to keep 3 RBs because we would already have a backup FB who can also carry the ball and we have multiple return guys. All were roles Sutton played in last season. He could also take back the starting kickoff return role he had at the beginning of the season. Also if he improves on his fumbling problems from last preseason, I think he could be a much better RB than Sutton. Plus I think taking a year to learn could do him much good. Also remember that Goodson is considered to be good at receiving as well. Besides I dont think the FO would cut a draft pick from last year because that will mean they just wasted a pick when they could've drafted someone else to stay on the roster.

[Kurb]

Sutton is solid pure rb option.

Goodson needs to prove he will put in the work to be the type of player he has the talent to be.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

Goodson, I think, has a ton of potential. That being said, I think Fox is clearly going with the guys who show the work ethic and play soundly. True, maybe Goodson didn't get his chance last year, but Sutton looked really good in his fairly-limited playing time.

I have to assume we'd go with Sutton over Goodson, since the coaching staff went with him last year.

[DudeNamedJeremy]

goodson showed a lot of potential but he fumbles too much

if i had to pick between the 2 id go with sutton.

[KillerKat]

Goodson, I think, has a ton of potential. That being said, I think Fox is clearly going with the guys who show the work ethic and play soundly. True, maybe Goodson didn't get his chance last year, but Sutton looked really good in his fairly-limited playing time.

I have to assume we'd go with Sutton over Goodson, since the coaching staff went with him last year.

True, but I think the reason Sutton was chosen over Goodson was because he wasn't quite ready yet. This year could be the year he shows who he truely is after taking a year to learn. And I think he will impress.

[OneBadassCat]

Goodson. He's got alot of talent and he impressed me personally in the preseason despite the fumble issue. Which I think is blown out of proportion anyway.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

True, but I think the reason Sutton was chosen over Goodson was because he wasn't quite ready yet. This year could be the year he shows who he truely is after taking a year to learn. And I think he will impress.

Could very well be, and I hope so. I had high hopes for Goodson as a slot receiver or returner.

But that thinking of "this could be his year" has been known to burn us before.

[nosuchthingasapanther]

sutton is nick goings 2.0 and is producing now.

goodson still has a lot to prove and hasn't produced much.

sutton > goodson.

[KillerKat]

Could very well be, and I hope so. I had high hopes for Goodson as a slot receiver or returner.

But that thinking of "this could be his year" has been known to burn us before.

Yeah but he was still just a rookie. I think the FO would be more willing to keep their 4th round pick of 2009 who has more potential. It's low risk, high reward and dumping him would just be an embarrassment.

[SOJA]

i would like to keep both but I'd take Sutton over Goodson

[jakesthemistake]

goodson will be a pro bowl WR some day

[OneBadassCat]

goodson will be a pro bowl WR some day

...

I don't know about that but he will have to have his poo ready. Because between Edwards, Goodson, Gettis, LaFell, and Jarrett someone(maybe more than 1) is going to be a great WR for us.

[Guild]

If we keep only one it is going to be the guy who has proven flexibility and production. Goodson hasn't been given the best chance imo and he may do well but I'm doubting it will be with us.

[WilkinsonDonnie]

Goodson fumbling problem isnt blown out of proportion, its a huge problem with a run first type of team. But I do feel he should/has to be better this year with that problem. Theres no way we cut a 4th round draft pick from last year with that much talent. Goodson will eventually be good.