Top 10 Panthers of ALL TIME

[Peppermint9030]

10. John Kasay

9. Jake Delhomme (Should be top 5)

8. Stephen Davis (not just for his amazing super bowl season, but also because he developed us into the mold that Carolina football is to day... A POWER run team.)

7. Deangello Williams and Jstew (already arguably the best running back duo EVER seen)

6. Wesley Walls

5. Mike Rucker (Class act)

4. Julius Peppers (Face of the defense for your years and an absolute freak)

3. Steve Smith (Triple Crown with colbert and carter next to you? The man is amazing!)

2. Sam Mills (RIP total class act as a player and coach)

....The number 1 Panther of ALL TIME is....

1. Mike Minter (The guy is the definition of PANTHER football, class act, big hitter, play maker, leader, spiritual, will be a Panther coach one day no doubt in my mind. The Sadest day for me besides Sam Mills dying was when Minter hung up the cleats. Easily number 1... those who dispute prove me wrong.)

NOT TO MENTION MINTER WAS TOTALLY FORGOTTEN BY EVERYONE B1TCHING IN THE GREG HARDY/PEPPERS THREAD.

[Zod]

Minter is not in the top 10. Probably not the top 20.

[XClown1986]

How is Moose not in there?

[Zod]

Jordan Gross is a top 10

[Squirrel]

No Kasay?

[Matt Foley]

Based on production at their position

10. Dan Morgan

9. Kris Jenkins

8. DeAngelo Williams

7. Jordan Gross

6. Sam Mills

5. Julius Peppers

4. Michael Bates

3. John Kasay

2. Steve Smith

1. Wesley Walls

[Highlandfire]

Minter is not in the top 10. Probably not the top 20.

Exactly! BTW what about steve beuerlein? The guy was a pretty damn good QB for us esp his over 4000 yard, 36 TD season.

Walls is 6th? He could be considered one of, if not the, best offensive weapon the Panthers have had. Smitty is on his heels of course.

Zod I really gotta wonder about the pure age of some of the posters here. I bet 80% of them couldn't tell you who took the first official game snap under center for us without looking it up.

[Jangler]

Zod I really gotta wonder about the pure age of some of the posters here. I bet 80% of them couldn't tell you who took the first official game snap under center for us without looking it up.

Uncle Rico

[Highlandfire]

uncle rico

exactly!

[coxc63]

10. Jake Delhomme

9. Muhsin Muhammed

8. Deangelo Williams/ Jonathan Stewart (will be higher on the list in a few years)

7. Mike Rucker

6. Dan Morgan

5. Wesley Walls (My favorite player of all time)

4. Sam Mills

3. Jon Beason

2. Julius Peppers

1a. Steve Smith

1b. Mike Minter

I know its 11 players but its a tie for first place. I have never seen anyone in my life with the willpower and determination that steve smith has, and there has never been any player to wear a panthers jersey with the class and leadership than Minter.

[Khyber53]

10. Steve Beurlein

9. Hoooover

8. Double Trouble (with a bullet)

7. Mike Minter

6. Mooooose

5. Jon Kasay

4. Jake Delhomme

3. Julius Peppers

2. Wesley Walls

1a. Steve Smith

1b. Jerry Richardson (not a Panther player, but without him, well, where would be?)

[Zod]

So you are talking favorite players, not best players.

[coxc63]

10. Jake Delhomme

9. Muhsin Muhammed

8. Deangelo Williams/ Jonathan Stewart (will be higher on the list in a few years)

7. Mike Rucker

6. Dan Morgan

5. Wesley Walls (My favorite player of all time)

4. Sam Mills

3. Jon Beason

2. Julius Peppers

1a. Steve Smith

1b. Mike Minter

I know its 11 players but its a tie for first place. I have never seen anyone in my life with the willpower and determination that steve smith has, and there has never been any player to wear a panthers jersey with the class and leadership than Minter.

[Brandon]

#1 is John Kasay. There is no substitute, he has been one of the best kickers in the league since we became a franchise.