I caught over 100 punts in camp, that's not an excuse anymore

[pantherfan49]

Jerry Richardson could further tighten the belt at BOA by making AE mow the grounds. Just a thought.

[Khyber53]

He'll work out, give it some time and the start of real football.

[Samuel L. Jackson]

Notice I said "bust at WR" I know he had a great year at return man and I'm not saying AE will be another Steve Smith!

Not trying to compare the two as much as I was trying to say players do develope over "time" <- there's that word again.

And BTW according to panthers.com Steve Smith's total Receiving TD's in his rookie season was 0. :sifone:

FYI, his first touch was a kick return against the Vikings, and therefore would not show up as a receiving touchdown...

Your point is moot anyways, because there will never be, especially Armanti Edwards, another Smitty...

[asupanther]

FYI, his first touch was a kick return against the Vikings, and therefore would not show up as a receiving touchdown...

Your point is moot anyways, because there will never be, especially Armanti Edwards, another Smitty...

Again, we are talking as a WR here: I said at the start that I know Smith had a Great year as a PR/KR.

Let's all just hope later this year we can pull this thread back up and say wow he did turn in a great player!

[Samuel L. Jackson]

hahah I'm only trying to argue/troll you bro... it's all good!

I just want all our players to be good...

[asupanther]

hahah I'm only trying to argue/troll you bro... it's all good!

I just want all our players to be good...

I'm with ya.

Sometimes i have a hard time keepin my App Homerism in check..but that's what fans to right..

[Panthro]

It's not hard to keep in check when you are actually talking about good players

ie Phillip Rivers, Torry Holt, Adrian Wilson, and Mario Williams

[asupanther]

oh no....here comes that homerism.....

good players huh...

Only player to ever win the Walter Payton Award - given annually to the nation's top NCAA Division I FCS player - twice, capturing the honor in 2008 and 2009...Four-time All-American...Led the Mountaineers to the NCAA Division I FCS national championship in 2006 and 2007...Holds virtually every school and Southern Conference record by a quarterback...Completed 768-of-1,180 passes for 10,392 yards and 74 touchdowns with 33 interceptions...Rushed for 4,361 yards and 65 touchdowns on 755 carries...Became the first player in NCAA Division I history - FCS or FBS - to pass for more than 10,000 yards and rush for more than 4,000 yards in a career...14,753 yards of total offense rank second in NCAA Division I FCS history, topped by the 16,823 yards of Steve McNair of Alcorn State from 1991-94...2009

come on give the kid his due respect, no matter what division FCS or FBS he had an outstanding college career

[Zod]

It's not hard to keep in check when you are actually talking about good players

ie Phillip Rivers, Torry Holt, Adrian Wilson, and Mario Williams

None of which returns punts!

I win

/thread

[WhiteBoysCanRun22]

My predicition is Armanti will stick as a #3 or #4 WR & eventually be given another shot @ PR by midseason

[Panthro]

oh no....here comes that homerism.....

good players huh...

Only player to ever win the Walter Payton Award - given annually to the nation's top NCAA Division I FCS player - twice,

So thats like a highschool giving out awards to the JV Football team.

[Floppin]

So thats like a highschool giving out awards to the JV Football team.

You just can't help yourself can you?

[monstercat]

It's not hard to keep in check when you are actually talking about good players

ie Phillip Rivers, Torry Holt, Adrian Wilson, and Mario Williams

That's all well and good, except that none of those guys play for the Panthers, so who cares?

[Khyber53]

That's all well and good, except that none of those guys play for the Panthers, so who cares?

Well, they did play for NC State, which makes it an even bigger Who Cares?

He's a State fan! :rofl: