Is it time to break up Panthers, trade Smith?

[WeWantBill]

It seems impossible for some people to see a guy, like Smith, as anything but self centered, pensive and spoiled would be too much to ask Dpantherman. The kind of guy who would break his body, give 110% and only want to be in every play...how crass!

I'll take $1.00 for everytime SS has sat stern and pensive on the sidelines alone, and live quite comfortable.

^^ I'm on this wagon

[panthers55]

Kicked off the team?? this is not high school football. yeah it was wrong but we all know as long as you can play at a high level most teams are willing to put up with a diva.

The guys in the FO dont care if he is a punk or not.The question is can he play and help me win? and that would be a yes

You are totally missing the point. The question was what could we get if we traded Smitty. I said no better than a second which is what Miami paid for Marshall who is younger than Smitty and seen pretty much as a bad boy like Smith.

The issue of how our FO likes him or how important he is to our team is totally off the subject and irrelevant. If you follpwed the discussion I already said I wouldn't trade him for a second and would in fact boycott the team this year if they traded him.

What are you even arguing about??? I was talking about how other fans around the league saw him and you are arguing you don't agree. The point isn't who is right but the perception around the league which would lessen his trade value. Are you saying other people don't think that about Smitty??

[GreekPanther]

#89 IS NOT GETTING TRADED BOTTOM LINE.....can we please end this thread now? thanks

[GreekPanther]

#89 IS NOT GETTING TRADED BOTTOM LINE....can we please end this thread now? thanks

[scpanther22]

You are totally missing the point. The question was what could we get if we traded Smitty. I said no better than a second which is what Miami paid for Marshall who is younger than Smitty and seen pretty much as a bad boy like Smith.

The issue of how our FO likes him or how important he is to our team is totally off the subject and irrelevant. If you follpwed the discussion I already said I wouldn't trade him for a second and would in fact boycott the team this year if they traded him.

What are you even arguing about??? I was talking about how other fans around the league saw him and you are arguing you don't agree. The point isn't who is right but the perception around the league which would lessen his trade value. Are you saying other people don't think that about Smitty??

I agree..but all I am saying is if we did trade smith I feel teams will look past his issues..

[panthers55]

I agree..but all I am saying is if we did trade smith I feel teams will look past his issues..

He is not as hot a commodity as people here think especially in today's market. That is why he won't be traded.

[Mr. Scot]

and it would be Tom Terrific wouldn't it? Which one of you is Tom? I know he lurks!!

I haven't been accused of that one yet. Ditto Joe Person.

(is there a more generic name in the world?)

I'm not up for trading Smith at this point.

[brandon_87]

I can't believe this thread is still going, this is non sense, smitty is a damn competitor. And of course he is mad, we aren't winning, but I bet he doesn't wanna leave, I can't believe this poo even got posted

[Squirrel]

I haven't been accused of that one yet. Ditto Joe Person.

(is there a more generic name in the world?)

I'm not up for trading Smith at this point.

We know who you are Mr. Fowler.

[2plankingpanther]

You must be Tom Sorensen!

[Mr. Scot]

Figures

[replive]

mr scot is really sorenson, but he posts rationally and objectively on the forum to throw people off.

i see through your ruse mr scot

[Mr. Scot]

I swear, I'm me

[replive]

i see you've only given out one pie slice in your whole forum posting career.

only sorenson would be that stingy with pie. there can be only one conclusion.