Bryce Young is the worst QB in Panthers History

[PghPanther]

Imagine if you are a DC and you are playing the Panthers with Young at QB......

...think how focused you could be to key off against the Panthers offense knowing there are certain physical skill sets that limits what Young can do in the QB position and how that allows you to manipulate and exploit the Panthers attempt to move the ball on key downs with Young behind center....

You just can't have a lack of options in the QB position in the NFL that most QB are all expected to have in their tool box. 

Hey wait...........can Young punt???

[Joe Bear]

3 minutes ago, SmokinwithWilly said:

Frank didn't suck. He knew week 1 of practice he didn't want to do 4 years of this poo. 

Frank sucked.

[Joe Bear]

5 minutes ago, CRA said:

The offense flat out didn’t do their job well enough for the majority of the game.   They didn’t exist.  Thats not even controversial.   A controversial take is wanting to cut the QB out of that 

There's a difference between cutting the QB out of that, and cutting the whole franchise out of it and only blaming the QB.

[ForJimmy]

Just now, CRA said:

Top 10 rush D, bottom 10 pass D.   6 minutes left in the game….we had a grand total of 7 points on the board largely thanks to the D putting the ball on the 19.   We didn’t convert 1 3rd down then

The offense flat out didn’t do their job well enough for the majority of the game.   They didn’t exist.  Thats not even controversial.   A controversial take is wanting to cut the QB out of that 

They just allowed 145 rushing yards to the Dolphins last week. If you are averaging 1.2 rushing yards per attempt you aren’t winning that game unless you have a top passing offense. Running game is our strength on offense right? Their time of possession was over 15 minutes more because they could run the ball and we couldn’t. There has to be an ounce of balance for most offenses to work. I know you know this. We beat them by 3 at home two weeks ago because we were able to have some balance. That balance didn’t exist today because of the running game. 

[SmokinwithWilly]

1 minute ago, Joe Bear said:

Frank sucked.

Because he didn't care anymore. He didn't want Bryce. Bryce didn't fit his offensive mold at QB. Tepper picked his QB for him. Look at his demeanor before and after the draft. Can't work for a boss that lies to your face. 

[Joe Bear]

Just now, SmokinwithWilly said:

Because he didn't care anymore. He didn't want Bryce. Bryce didn't fit his offensive mold at QB. Tepper picked his QB for him. Look at his demeanor before and after the draft. Can't work for a boss that lies to your face. 

Then he should've quit before the season started. 

[CRA]

Just now, Joe Bear said:

There's a difference between cutting the QB out of that, and cutting the whole franchise out of it and only blaming the QB.

no one sincerely cuts the whole franchise out of it and only blames the QB.  

[ForJimmy]

7 minutes ago, TN05 said:

CRA doesn't even watch the games, usually. He just looks at statlines.

He knows his stuff. I think he picks some of these arguments out of boredom or just to debate. I can understand him wanting to move on from Bryce. I’m for it if that’s what we decide. He just wasn’t on the top of my list of issues this week. Last week is a different story. 

[Joe Bear]

5 minutes ago, CRA said:

no one sincerely cuts the whole franchise out of it and only blames the QB.  

The first page of this forum begs to differ.

[strato]

5 minutes ago, Joe Bear said:

The first page of this forum begs to differ.

That is because of three years of enduring Bryce’s college ball in the NFL. Three years. Same issues. People are sick of it. 

[CRA]

2 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

They just allowed 145 rushing yards to the Dolphins last week. If you are averaging 1.2 rushing yards per attempt you aren’t winning that game unless you have a top passing offense. Running game is our strength on offense right? Their time of possession was over 15 minutes more because they could run the ball and we couldn’t. There has to be an ounce of balance for most offenses to work. I know you know this. We beat them by 3 at home two weeks ago because we were able to have some balance. That balance didn’t exist today because of the running game. 

Sure but plenty of NFL games go down where balance and ideals go out the window.  Thats just football sometimes.  

You can find lots of examples of where teams have had virtually no run game in certain weeks and it got clamped ….We also couldn’t convert a single 3rd down.  Thats got something to do with TOP too.

We all know this pass game isn’t good enough and it starts with Bryce and Dave being the two biggest key for why.  If we want to not be bottom 3rd in 2026….the answer probably has less to do with finding another WR than it does Bryce 

[strato]

14 minutes ago, SmokinwithWilly said:

Because he didn't care anymore. He didn't want Bryce. Bryce didn't fit his offensive mold at QB. Tepper picked his QB for him. Look at his demeanor before and after the draft. Can't work for a boss that lies to your face. 

That was as plain as the defeated look on Frank’s face. 

[Joe Bear]

1 minute ago, strato said:

That is because of three years of enduring Bryce’s college ball in the NFL. Three years. Same issues. People are sick of it. 

It's fine to blame him for what he does or doesn't do, but blaming him for everyone else's mistakes is lazy and stupid. People get sick of that, too.

[CRA]

19 minutes ago, Joe Bear said:

The first page of this forum begs to differ.

I’m as big of a Bryce hater as anyone here.  It’s not just Bryce.  And I really can’t  think of a fellow hater that believes it’s just him.   

but Bryce in no way at this stage projects to be a great QB in time.   He is low ceiling and inconsistent.   

2 biggest game changers a team can find are a great coach or QB….so it is what it is.  He occupies a role that if filled with a better player has a lot of impact