Siefert on Newton - Myth & Reality

[raleigh-panther]

I am neither pro or anti Newton.

Like all things, posted on this board, the value is in the reader's eyes.

[Verge]

is there an elite qb today that blew ass in college like gabbert?

Yes.

Tom Brady. - 20 tds, 6 int

Brett Favre - 16 tds, 5 int (his best year, not putting his final year because they ran so much)

Good/Great qbs

Joe Flaaco - 23 tds, 5 int

Donovan McNabb - 22 tds, 5 int

Matt Cassell - 0 tds, 0 int

Jay Cutler - 21 tds, 9 int

Aaaron Rodgers - 24 tds, 8 int

Kurt Warner - 17 tds, 9 int

Matt Hasselbeck - 11 tds , 10 int

Josh Freeman - 20 tds, 8 int

And those are only current qbs (except Warner), you don't have to throw for 90 tds to be a good nfl qb.

Most comparable to Gabbert Kurt Warner, Jay Cutler, Brett Favre, and Aaaron Rodgers.

Similar stats due to the team around them sucking.

[teeray]

Yes.

Tom Brady. - 20 tds, 6 int

Brett Favre - 16 tds, 5 int (his best year, not putting his final year because they ran so much)

Good/Great qbs

Joe Flaaco - 23 tds, 5 int

Donovan McNabb - 22 tds, 5 int

Matt Cassell - 0 tds, 0 int

Jay Cutler - 21 tds, 9 int

Aaaron Rodgers - 24 tds, 8 int

Kurt Warner - 17 tds, 9 int

Matt Hasselbeck - 11 tds , 10 int

Josh Freeman - 20 tds, 8 int

And those are only current qbs (except Warner), you don't have to throw for 90 tds to be a good nfl qb.

Most comparable to Gabbert Kurt Warner, Jay Cutler, Brett Favre, and Aaaron Rodgers.

Similar stats due to the team around them sucking.

Literally every one of those except Hasselbeck was better than Gabbert. I know what you point is though I am just busting you balls.

[Verge]

Literally every one of those except Hasselbeck was better than Gabbert. I know what you point is though I am just busting you balls.

Gabbert was better than Cassell, Favre, and Warner as well =P

[teeray]

Yeah. 0 tds and 0 ints is pretty hard to top. :lol:

[Verge]

Yeah. 0 tds and 0 ints is pretty hard to top. :lol:

Pretty good interception ratio though ;]

[jtnc]

Gabbert was better than Cassell, Favre, and Warner as well =P

You're delusional. Just because Gabbert was better than Favre and Warner in COLLEGE doesn't mean those stats will transition to the NFL.

[Verge]

You're delusional. Just because Gabbert was better than Favre and Warner in COLLEGE doesn't mean those stats will transition to the NFL.

....Yeah...I know.

That is EXACTLY what I was pointing out.

[TheRealDeal]

But it does for Newton?

[Verge]

But it does for Newton?

No rule applies to Newton, he is Jesus...remember?

[jtnc]

But it does for Newton?

Jeez, never said that. Wrong guy

[TheRealDeal]

I didn't quote you, just a general question.

Most people fall back on newton's title win and his amazing stats in college as the reason he will be successful in the NFL.

It doesn't work that way.

[jtnc]

The thing that worries me is Gabbert's accuracy.

[teeray]

No rule applies to Newton, he is Jesus...remember?

Sorry thought you already knew (maybe you do):

Andrew Luck is God

Cam Newton is Jesus

And Blaine Gabbert is Judas.

That is why Gabbert isn't very popular.