QB Camp: Newton

[Mr. Scot]

I am just saying, real competitors want the ball in their hands at the end of the game, and those are the guys I want on my team.

What you just described I have no problem with.

A guy disobeying a coaches order? Not so good.

[teeray]

I am just saying, real competitors want the ball in their hands at the end of the game, and those are the guys I want on my team.

[Mr. Scot]

Why compare Cam to PeyPey? He's a Big Ben clone if things turn out right.

If he ever had the brains/accuracy anywhere close to Manning he'd be the greatest player the NFL has ever seen.

What you have to hope is that he doesn't have the brains of Roethlisberger.

[teeray]

What you just described I have no problem with.

A guy disobeying a coaches order? Not so good.

What were Chizik's orders?? Can you confirm that he didn't tell him "if you see something you like go ahead and score."?

*I realize this pic is obnoxious but I have to have a pic. :mad:

[Mr. Scot]

What were Chizik's orders?? Can you confirm that he didn't tell him "if you see something you like go ahead and score."?

*I realize this pic is obnoxious but I have to have a pic. :mad:

If that had been the situation, there never would have been a story in the first place.

Chizik has never said "I gave him permission to freelance".

[teeray]

I never said you should care. I said I care. If you don't care, that doesn't bother me at all. All I said was I didn't like his answer. I didn't say "AND TEERAY YOU SHOULDN'T EITHER!!!"

MAV you just asked me the post above if I cared. :D :D

[Icege]

And that what makes me more comfortable with Cam.

Cam and Pete Carrol? No way.

Cam and Fox? Eh, dont like it.

Cam and Rivera? I think Cam will know his place.

Rivera being here makes me feel a lot more at ease with a lot of these high-risk guys as well.

Teeray: Normally I enjoy your banter, but let's be reasonable for a moment. You have now claimed that because Peyton Manning waved off the punt team during his 7th season in the NFL (after already being a x4 Pro Bowler, x2 AFC PotY, AP NFL MVP, and on his way that season to another Pro Bowl, AFC Player of the Year, and AP NFL MVP award each), that it was okay for Cam Newton during his first season as the starter for Auburn during the National Championship game to not listen to his coach during the final moments of the entire season and his college career?

Can we extend that gag order until May 28th?

[mav1234]

There is no way the play call was "if the defense lines up like this, QB sneak, if not, take a knee," because then it wouldn't have gotten leaked he disobeyed orders to take a knee.

[teeray]

If that had been the situation, there never would have been a story in the first place.

Chizik has never said "I gave him permission to freelance".

The story was created by the media. :eek: The speculated because they were in victory formation. They are probably right. But we don't know that for sure.

[mav1234]

MAV you just asked me the post above if I cared. :D :D

Why exactly do you bother with the pictures when you are posting things anyway? You are far more annoying with all these idiotic images.

I didn't tell you TO care I asked you if you DID care. I'm explaining why *I* didn't like his answer, and was asking if given that perspective if you could see why I felt that way. Apparently not.

[Sch25]

What you have to hope is that he doesn't have the brains of Roethlisberger.

Man, you have no idea. I'm from the Pittsburgh area and if even 1/4 of the stories are true... What a tool.

[mav1234]

The story was created by the media. :eek: The speculated because they were in victory formation. They are probably right. But we don't know that for sure.

Some FO had as much to do with creating a furor over it as any media group, since they're the ones that asked him about it at the combine and caused a bit furor over it after that. The FO wasn't speculating; they were told that is what happened, or so it was made out to be.

People at Auburn have been quick to defend him, so why wouldn't they have said "nah, it was a called QB sneak if it was there" instead of saying "yeah well we don't care that he went against the play call"? Meh.

[teeray]

Why exactly do you bother with the pictures when you are posting things anyway? You are far more annoying with all these idiotic images.

I didn't tell you TO care I asked you if you DID care. I'm explaining why *I* didn't like his answer, and was asking if given that perspective if you could see why I felt that way. Apparently not.

You care if a Heisman Trophy winner does it on his college team but not when Peyton Manning does it??

:)

[Mr. Scot]

Man, you have no idea. I'm from the Pittsburgh area and if even 1/4 of the stories are true... What a tool.

I'd be willing to bet way more than just a quarter of the stories are true.