Jump to content

  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Newton vs. Tebow

CarolinaCatBrigade

By CarolinaCatBrigade,
in Carolina Panthers

Recommended Posts

TheRealDeal Newbie

TheRealDeal

Posted
Posted

Okay, so to get back on topic - measuring a QB by wins alone (especially a rookie QB) is foolish. Comparing two QB's on wins alone is foolish. The Golden Calf of Bristol plays like crap against the 2nd worst team in the NFL and barely gets the win, then he plays a good team and is buried, then he beats a so-so team with a gimmick offense, how does this compare to what Cam has done?

It's really hard to compare. Cam is in a totally different offense with better weapons at each and every skill position and a better offensive line. Offensively, we are better at all 10 other positions. We run a better scheme stat wise and have played many of the worst defenses in the league. The only top 10 defense we played Cam put up 150 yards, 50% and 1 TD, but it happened to be in a monsoon.

In other games Cam has put up a lot of yards, but not a lot of points. He's beaten 2 of the worst teams in the league and lost to everyone else.

I think he's better than The Golden Calf of Bristol (which isn't saying much) but it's just an opinion. They are in such different situations that it's very dumb to compare. It's similar to the Dalton argument.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
CatMan72 Enthusiast

CatMan72

Posted
Posted

It's really hard to compare. Cam is in a totally different offense with better weapons at each and every skill position and a better offensive line. Offensively, we are better at all 10 other positions. We run a better scheme stat wise and have played many of the worst defenses in the league. The only top 10 defense we played Cam put up 150 yards, 50% and 1 TD, but it happened to be in a monsoon.

In other games Cam has put up a lot of yards, but not a lot of points. He's beaten 2 of the worst teams in the league and lost to everyone else.

I think he's better than The Golden Calf of Bristol (which isn't saying much) but it's just an opinion. They are in such different situations that it's very dumb to compare. It's similar to the Dalton argument.

It's hard to compare? :lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
TheRealDeal Newbie

TheRealDeal

Posted
Posted

LOL, it's hard to compare? :lol:

I mean, it's easy for you to compare, you are a Cam fan. I'm don't think he's doing what Cam is doing in this offense, but it might be a discussion with guys like Mallet, Locker, Dalton, etc.

No one thought Anderson was any good yet he was a probowler in this offense and he didn't have near the weapons we do now. It's a huge matter of circumstance and hypotheticals which is why it's difficult to compare guys in two completely different systems with completely different talent levels around them.

I think most people would agree that Cam is better than The Golden Calf of Bristol, but in other situations (maybe some not involving Cam) comparing guys gets a little shady.

We tried to do it for years with Smitty. "man, if he had a QB, he'd put up 2,000 yard seasons no doubt" "He's way better than Fitz/Moss/Harrison/Megatron/AJ/etc because if he had their QB/System/2nd WR, he'd be killing it"

Just the nature of the beast I guess.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
CatMan72 Enthusiast

CatMan72

Posted
Posted

I mean, it's easy for you to compare, you are a Cam fan. I'm don't think he's doing what Cam is doing in this offense, but it might be a discussion with guys like Mallet, Locker, Dalton, etc.

No one thought Anderson was any good yet he was a probowler in this offense and he didn't have near the weapons we do now. It's a huge matter of circumstance and hypotheticals which is why it's difficult to compare guys in two completely different systems with completely different talent levels around them.

I think most people would agree that Cam is better than The Golden Calf of Bristol, but in other situations (maybe some not involving Cam) comparing guys gets a little shady.

We tried to do it for years with Smitty. "man, if he had a QB, he'd put up 2,000 yard seasons no doubt" "He's way better than Fitz/Moss/Harrison/Megatron/AJ/etc because if he had their QB/System/2nd WR, he'd be killing it"

Just the nature of the beast I guess.

Shouldn't we wait for Mallet and Locker to play a regular season game?

Dalton is the only viable comparison since he's also a rookie, and when you get past the wins and look at what Dalton is being asked to do, there really is no comparison.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
TheRealDeal Newbie

TheRealDeal

Posted
Posted

Shouldn't we wait for Mallet and Locker to play a regular season game?

Dalton is the only viable comparison since he's also a rookie, and when you get past the wins and look at what Dalton is being asked to do, there really is no comparison.

And that is exactly why it's hard to compare.

Dalton isn't being asked to throw for 300 yards a game. He might be capable but we don't know. All we know is that he does his job successfully. He also doesn't have the playmakers we have.

Just because he's not in the gun, throwing 40 times a game doesn't mean he can't, he's simply not being asked too. He's executing his game plan successfully and you can't knock him for that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
WilliamsR Newbie

WilliamsR

Posted
Posted

The Golden Calf of Bristol is no where near as good as Newton. His team has more wins b/c their defense has been able to keep them alive by stopping drives at key times in the game. Our defense has not done that. When we've needed a stop, we haven't been able to get it.

While our defense certainly let us down at times during the game, it's gotten teams of the field in order to give the offense a chance to be either tied or down by one score in the 4th. And it usually stepped up in the 4th quarter. We've averaged 2 possessions per 4th quarter with the game still within one score to go win the game before we finally got burnt.

Not sure how many more chances one would expect but there have been at least two games when the offense went for 20-25 minutes without scoring on at least 2 occasions I can remember off the top of my head.

We've had 14 possessions, all either tying or game winning opportunities, and we were successful on 1. I'm still trying to figure out how people can overlook this.

3 and outs go both ways.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
X-Clown Veteran

X-Clown

Posted
Posted

It's really hard to compare. Cam is in a totally different offense with better weapons at each and every skill position and a better offensive line. Offensively, we are better at all 10 other positions. We run a better scheme stat wise and have played many of the worst defenses in the league. The only top 10 defense we played Cam put up 150 yards, 50% and 1 TD, but it happened to be in a monsoon.

In other games Cam has put up a lot of yards, but not a lot of points. He's beaten 2 of the worst teams in the league and lost to everyone else.

I think he's better than The Golden Calf of Bristol (which isn't saying much) but it's just an opinion. They are in such different situations that it's very dumb to compare. It's similar to the Dalton argument.

Checklist for "objective" posts from TRD about Cam as compared to any other QB

1. Throw one line of half hearted praise for what Cam has done so far to "prove" objectivity.

Check

2. Explain away any stats that are positive as just stats (i.e. it's because everyone else on the offense boosts up Cam, it's because he played bad defenses, etc)

Check

3. Point out wins as a stat that are attributable to QBs, but don't bring up other units that have quite a bit to do with wins as being part of what helps a team win games (i.e. special teams and defense)

Check

4. However, any random stat that is negative is important (i.e. the only top 10 defense he's played is the Jags and his stats weren't good in that game.)

Check

Link to comment
Share on other sites
TheRealDeal Newbie

TheRealDeal

Posted
Posted

4. However, any random stat that is negative is important (i.e. the only top 10 defense he's played is the Jags and his stats weren't good in that game.)

Check

Please let the record show that I also noted it was in a monsoon in fairness to Cam, but don't let that ruin your fun.

Please continue.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
mav1234 Grand Master

mav1234

Posted
Posted

man I swear to god you guys go into posts deciding to read them a certain way. I did not see that TRD post as him going "LOL The Golden Calf of Bristol >>> CAM CAM SUCKS LOL" I saw it as him saying "This is why it's hard to directly compare Cam with anyone right now."

And he's right... All you can really say is that Cam has been playing way better than expected and looks to be a future star here. If we keep this offense together, we'll light the league on fire. That's not to say that we couldn't still have a good offense without the weapons we have now, but man, our entire offense is clicking so well... and that's with all the "rabble rabble legedu" stuff... I think we have plenty of praise to hand out, and Cam isn't the only one that deserves it so far on the offensive end.

Best part is, they can still get better.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
TheRealDeal Newbie

TheRealDeal

Posted
Posted

X-Clown, what part do you disagree with?

Are we not better on offense at skill positions? Line? Scheme? Were the Jags not the only top 10 defense we played? Was it not in a monsoon? Were Cam's numbers not very pedestrian? Did he not beat the Jags and Skins (who haven't won a game with Beck and all the injuries)? Do you not think he is better than The Golden Calf of Bristol? Do you not think they are in different situations?

I'd love to know

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • TheCandyMan
      Canes vs Golden Knights Gm 2 SCF 8pm

      By TheCandyMan · Posted

      I agree with you in that I think we can take one on the road, two against this opponent would be a tall order.  Not impossible, but we'd be making it awfully hard on ourselves.
    • Anybodyhome
      Larkin for Aho

      By Anybodyhome · Posted

      Dylan Larkin has requested a trade from the Red Wings: https://thescore.com/nhl/news/3550045 Trade Aho for Larkin. Work it out. Whatever it takes. I've always liked Larkin's game and I think he'd be a great fit alongside Jarvy and Svech.
    • Basbear
      Myles Garrett Traded to Rams

      By Basbear · Posted

      This is a how I recall it as well. It was one "this year" 2nd and two future 1sts. Very few are able to predict the future, but I feel you had to label those 1st as late 20s. The true blunder was what you stated, before you turn down that massive offer, its a 100% must you sign Burns cause that value is still elite QB level offer. As we know either happened and Dan was a first time GM needing to fix this blunder of blunders. He or the group made the choice about not giving BB 30 per, I get it since he had holes in his game.  The issue here is the issue since 2018= tepper. Sometime either during the hiring process or with the two years, Im fairly certain trepper demanded a QB on the roster with a capable roster to compete. Fittererererererer job was on the line and he gassed up trepper into believing BY and the roster were ready to win..................... That roster of 2023 in hindsight was awful, I was wrong....... I thought even with a rookie BY they could have challenged for the NFC south, not a chance with that dogshit team and coaching staff.......whom I was also fooled about. Now you have the worst team 2-14 without 1st overall pick, DJ Moore, and no Brian Burns.  I don't know what or why or ____ just the panthers and finding good WRs with long careers is just cursed. You got Smitty and moose, that's about it for 25 years until they drafted DJ Moore.....so 3 dudes in 26+ years AND you trade one for a QB whom needs a team that doesn't struggle to find WRs......... Fittererererere was just like Morgan, he was a rookie GM and this team even back to 2020 just has failed at adding talent, young talent, or difference makers. Even look at the roster- Dbrown is about the only great player drafted in what feels like 10 years(horn struggles and tmac only 1 year)..... Treppers pressure is legend and him bringing in people with such little exp to fix the team was the main reason for 2 win 5 win seasons. He should have hired a old gray haired guy, but I know treppers ego would not allow someone else to have the answer.  I've work with teppers type and still do...... Smart people observing them know "if its not their idea, they want nothing to do with cause weird human reasons" Doesnt matter if my idea can solve the issues with 24 hours and it 100% corrects the problem, nah his plan is for 3 weeks with different Appaloosa Strategies.......... I do think he finally took a few steps back and allowed Dan and Daves staff to learn on the job, he had no choice given the league refused his money. 
×
×
  • Create New...