Which Panther player would you pick?

[Cat Fanboy]

If they were playing in their prime?

Steve Buerlein v Vinny Testeverde?

Kevin Greene v Julius Peppers?

Beason v Sam Mills?

Walls v Shockey/Olsen?

Stephen Davis v DeAngelo Williams?

He Hate Me v Michael Bates?

For myself I like:

Vinny

Greene

Beason

Walls

Davis

Bates.

:cheers2:

[KillerKat]

Beuerlein

Greene

Beason

Walls

Williams

Bates

How the f**k you pick Vinny over Beuerlein?

Edit: Vinny

[liljah8303]

Vinny

Peppers

Beason

Shockey

Deangelo

Bates.

Cam

[KillerKat]

My bad Vinny had a good 98 season too. So I change mine

[KillerKat]

101.6 QB rating...jezuz

[PantherBase]

Vinny

Peppers

Beason

Walls

Williams

Bates

[Donald LaFell]

how are bates and smart even comparable? Should be vs. smitty(KR/PR)

[HominyISharmonious]

Steve Buerlein - Always liked him

Kevin Greene - Was a better teammate

Mills - Easy, not even close

Walls - Lol, it takes two guys to replace him.

Williams - more speed

Bates - Still looking for his replacement

[Cat Fanboy]

lol - I know...just always liked He Hate Me and couldnt find anyone close to comparing him. :)

The WR was tricky too. Muhammad v Proehl?

or

Foster v Tiakabutka? :)

[csx]

Walls in this offense would be fun

[HominyISharmonious]

Proehl, another fav.

[LionsFanVisiting]

New guy here..

Saw the name Kevin Greene, thought id share a story about him.

When I was young I saw him in person and because he just had a little spell on WCW and got choke slammed by The Giant, i yelled to him, "Hey Kevin, How does it feel to get choke slammed by The Giant?!" (not knowing how great of a player he was) He stopped...looked at me, and ran like a bull right up to my face and yelled, "How do you think it felt, I practically got knocked out!" He was just joking, gave me an autograph and all. Nice guy....thought id share that.

[jamos14]

Kevin wasn't here very long but he was a hell of a linebacker/de

[philw5289]

Buerlein

Peppers

Beason

Walls

Williams

He hate me