My big board (40)

[Verge]

1. Shariff Floyd

2. Eric Fisher

3. Luke Joeckel

4. Barkevious Mingo

5. Dion Jordan

6. Chance Warmack

7. Sheldon Richardson

8. Ziggy Ansah

9. Tavon Austin

10. Jonathan Cooper

11. DJ Hayden

12. Tyler Eifert

13. Lane Johnson

14. Dee Milliner

15. Geno Smith

16. Kenny Vaccaro

17. Jarvis Jones

18. Tank Caradine/Jamar Taylor

19. Cordarelle Patterson

20. Star Lotuleilei

21. Sylvester Williams

22. EJ Manuel

23. Matt Elam

24. Deandre Hopkins

25. DJ Fluker

26. Alec Ogletree

27. Justin Hunter

28. Desmond Trufant

29. Datone Jones

30. Menelik Watson

31. Bjoern Werner

32. Eric Reid

33. Arthur Brown

34. Kawaan Short

35. Margus Hunt

36. Jonathan Cyprien

37. Kevin Minter

38. Justin Pugh

39. Keenan Allen

40. Kyle Long

[Swaggasaurus]

Why the love for two DT's that can't sack the QB or make TFL and get pushed around against the run? I don't get what so many people see about Floyd and Richardson that makes them top talent. Sorry ass run defenders who pressure, but do not seal the deal, that is what I see.

[carolina-chuck]

I quit when I couldn't find Star in the top 15

[carpanfan96]

Switch Star and Geno. While I'm not crazy about Star, he's at least a top 15 guy and is a better prospect then Geno Smith.

[Verge]

I quit when I couldn't find Star in the top 15

I do not understand the obsession dude. He is a damn good 3-4 DE/NT, but a 4-3 DT? No.

He makes around four impact plays and was not that important to the game, they only doubled him a couple of times and was generally contained. Yes, he can push himself forward and beat a center, but he is not getting constant pressure and tends to get pulled to often for my taste.

[nagai]

No Rhodes or Jamar Taylor?

[kman72]

Jesse Williams?

EJ and Geno are too high....

[Verge]

No Rhodes or Jamar Taylor?

Spaced on Taylor.

[nagai]

BTW, I still think this is awesome. Here's some news to everyone -- different people rate prospects differently. I think this is actually quite a realistic ranking, to some scouts anyway.

[TANTRIC-NINJA]

Xavier Rhodes said Whyyyyy!!

[carpanfan96]

I made it 5:20 into that video and I saw 8 double teams, 2 pressures and 1 QB hit as a NT. That isn't a big impact as a 4-3 NT? I'm just wondering. While I feel the same about him being overrated because of his technique issues, I also have to admit that's a pretty big impact for a 4-3 NT.

[carolina-chuck]

I do not understand the obsession dude. He is a damn good NT, but a 4-3 DT? No.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MQMb4NTEaIA

He makes around four impact plays and was not that important to the game, they only doubled him a couple of times and was generally contained. Yes, he can push himself forward and beat a center, but he is not getting constant pressure and tends to get pulled to often for my taste.

Star is a 43 NT dude. What are you taking about?

I think you're getting caught up way too much with Star being Haloti Ngata.

[Ken]

I stopped after seeing Floyd being #1

I really like Floyd but no way is he the best prospect in this draft....

[Panther4lyfe]

Sheldon Richardson is so overated it makes no sense. He gets pushed around in just about every run play. Yes he does make the play after the first down, but by that time who cares. I think that the experts have overhyped this guy to the max. And when you see the interviews you just get the feeling that he will be a bust.