Would you trade Cam Newton for Cleveland's 2 Number 1 picks?

[mav1234]

you never trade a quality, young QB... not even for 2 first rounders.

[mav1234]

I don't see Cleveland offering the 2 #1's, but I most certainly would, then I'd try(and likely fail) to parlay that into getting Eli Manning and Hakeem Nicks out of  New York. 

At 1-3 you are forced to think way outside the box...

 

hahah Eli Manning being traded are you fuging kidding me

 

I swear Madden has destroyed people's brains.  lol trading Eli Manning...

[Guest KingKam]

Easily. Would allow us to draft Hundley, Matthews, and a WR. Too bad CLE would never offer that. 

Well, Cleveland can keep all of that and win the next 10 superbowls. Cam stays.

[Shermdog]

NO.

[bigmanstew]

hahah Eli Manning being traded are you fuging kidding me

 

I swear Madden has destroyed people's brains.  lol trading Eli Manning...

No it's not likely. Not likely at all, but Nobody saw Trent Richardson getting moved either.  I haven't played Madden in years.  Half the Giants fans(idiots) want him gone, half want a new coach/oc/etc....  Like I said.. way outside the box.

[C47]

No it's not likely. Not likely at all, but Nobody saw Trent Richardson getting moved either.  I haven't played Madden in years.  Half the Giants fans(idiots) want him gone, half want a new coach/oc/etc....  Like I said.. way outside the box.

 

Writing was on the wall for Trent as soon as Chud took over. I thought it would take another year, but never expected Chud to keep Trent long term...

[mav1234]

Even if the Giants got a new coach, they wouldn't trade Eli.  He won them 2 Superbowls.  You don't ditch a QB like that.

[Guest KingKam]

Sounds kinda like Brandon LaFell kinda numbers...well save for the 4 less TDs.  Also, Welker had Brandon LaFell type numbers in Miami.  My point is, an average receiver becomes great with a great QB.  A WR like LaFell with Cam has still been...average.  

Well, we don't dink&dunk in carolina. those 4 yard route can do wonder for a little fella who can take a hit. That boy's gonna feel those hit a few years after retirement though.

 

[hepcat]

Well, we don't dink&dunk in carolina. those 4 yard route can do wonder for a little fella who can take a hit. That boy's gonna feel those hit a few years after retirement though.

 

 

And that, ladies and gentleman, is why these guys get paid millions of dollars. 

[restNChrist]

i would need at least 5 first rounds for cam.

 

this isn't a matter of cam being worth 5 first rounders, it's a matter of that's what we would need to improve with a new qb. if you think a rookie qb (bridgewater, for example, as he is a stud and best qb in the class) could come in and ball out with our supporting cast you are out of your mind.

 

point is no QB outside of the big 3 (brady, manning, rodgers) would be successful in our offense. that is a result of our lack of talent and terrible scheme.

I would add Brees

[thefuzz]

Honestly, if I'm DG, yes, you make that trade.

 

You would likely have two top 10's and a 25-28 or so pick.

 

If you are bringing in a new HC and full coaching staff, that is a lot to work with after blowing this roster up.

 

That said, will never, ever happen.

[hepcat]

Writing was on the wall for Trent as soon as Chud took over. I thought it would take another year, but never expected Chud to keep Trent long term...

 

Considering how low a value the running back position has become in the pass oriented NFL of today, the Browns made out like bandits getting a 1st round pick in return for Richardson.  Drafting a RB #3 overall is such a bad move considering you can get Trent Richardson's production from a running back drafted much later.  Watching the red zone channel yesterday, I was amazed at how many teams blindly throw the ball on every down.  The craziest of which was the Jacksonville Jaguars...who had the ball at the freaking goal line at least 3-4 times, and never ONCE ran the ball with Maurice Jones-Drew.  It was as if they wanted to lose.  

[bigmanstew]

Even if the Giants got a new coach, they wouldn't trade Eli.  He won them 2 Superbowls.  You don't ditch a QB like that.

His brother says Hello from Denver.

[mav1234]

His brother says Hello from Denver.

 

Do you really need me to remind you of the age difference and injury history in there?

 

Come on.  Present your idea in 5 years after Eli has been seriously injured and let's talk.