Cam or Eli ?

[frash.exe]

[Coug Girl]

Why Eli? Let's try our luck for Peyton. I'm sure the Broncos would say yes, right?

[KJ89]

Why Eli? Let's try our luck for Peyton. I'm sure the Broncos would say yes, right?

Now why the hell would they do that

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

here's the direct answer that this high quality thread surely deserves: no, the giants would not make that trade.

 

now, where do we go from there?

[carolinarolls]

I'm just curious to see how many people here think it would go through.

Aka how many people think the rest of the league sees things the way we see things.

It's not about the trade or who is better. Their situation happens to be middle if the road and they are generally well respected and seen as intelligent and stable as an organization. I thought it would be interesting.

Most here are not bright enough to recognize any significance in the question hence the ridiculous responses that had nothing to do with the topic but that comes to be expected after a while when posing pantherphann day care.

[TheRed]

Great thread from carolinarolls. Who knew it would be about Cam Newton, and totally absurd?

[Happy Panther]

Cam has regressed in his development. If you are the Giants you should be damn sure it's all because of coaching.

[carolinarolls]

TheRed continues to reveal more and more about herself.

[frash.exe]

[TheRed]

TheRed continues to reveal more and more about herself.

 

Oh man, gender insults. What do I do? I'm just so hurt.

[TheRed]

 

More of these please.

[bleys]

I'm just curious to see how many people here think it would go through.

Aka how many people think the rest of the league sees things the way we see things.

It's not about the trade or who is better. Their situation happens to be middle if the road and they are generally well respected and seen as intelligent and stable as an organization. I thought it would be interesting.

Most here are not bright enough to recognize any significance in the question hence the ridiculous responses that had nothing to do with the topic but that comes to be expected after a while when posing pantherphann day care.

 

You're asking a random question that has 2 perspective from both franchises, and neither which anyone here seems to care to expound upon because whatever brilliance you draw from the question itself, it's pointless.

 

Giants will not trade Eli because he's won 2 SBs and the time put into his development at a young 32 (still has 5-6 years easy) would be more beneficial to holding that team together than it would be taking a flyer on Cam.

 

Panthers have a young and upcoming QB who has proven he can toss the ball around the yard.  We obviously need new coaches, why would the Panthers EVER think it's a good idea to rebuild around a 32 year old QB?  

 

It's a moot point and brings no relevance to our situation today, which may be the real reason why you're getting so much backlash in this thread..  .  It proves nothing about Cam or Eli.  Circumstantially, both teams would be dumb to make that trade.

[carolinarolls]

Bleys it was just a simple question and to me it's quite relevant. I hear a host if excuses day in and day out and nothing has changed in 3 years.

I just wonder how many here would honestly admit to believing that others in the league would arrive at the same excuse driven conclusions even if all they had to risk was a marginal talent like Eli to find out.

You took it too far. I'm not proposing a trade, hypothesizing about the probability of a trade, or even interested in acquiring Eli Manning.

[Acewalker]