Saca312

In an article discussing a particular analyst's mock draft, a collection of quotes from several coaches who have faced off against the top quarterbacks is prominently featured. https://theathletic.com/4357004/2023/03/31/mock-draft-nfl-picks/ While the analyst in question has projected CJ Stroud as the Panthers' pick, that detail is not the primary focus. Instead, the crux of the article lies in the insights provided by various college coaches regarding these star quarterbacks. The following are selected excerpts from those coach's comments: CJ Stroud: On his processing and understanding of coverages: On his accuracy and timing: On his performance against one coach and his opinion on his ability: Bryce Young On his intelligence: On facing him and the coach's opinion on his ability to read coverages and be effective: On his athleticism and positives on durability: Criticisms durability concerns and translation of talent into the NFL:

I understand your point, it's definitely a valid one. I agree that at times, it would be beneficial to see Bryce maintain his poise in the pocket instead of running outside, as the play could have been there for him. However, I believe that the ability to play outside of structure is more valuable than playing within the structure. I feel it's preferable to have a quarterback who can improvise when things don't go as planned, especially since they may not always have an elite supporting cast throughout their career. Having someone who has shown effectiveness outside of structure and then teaching them how to play within the structure is more advantageous than asking a quarterback to learn how to play outside of the structure. Of course, this is just my opinion, and I can understand how in a fundamental system, Stroud's ability to hit quick and precise throws would be a better fit. Reich's system is tailor-made for that, and I can see the perspective of choosing Stroud as the #1 pick for that. Overall, they are both very close in terms of talent and ability. Both are deserving of the #1 overall pick, and it ultimately comes down to what the Carolina team values more and which quarterback is the best fit for their system.

I like CJ Stroud, but there is a risk factor in that he needs optimal conditions to succeed. His ability to play out of structure is subpar, with limited tape showing he can do so. His pressure QBR is about 70%, vs Bryce Young's appx 95%. Young's ability to maneuver in the pocket and out of structure is uncanny and without doubt one of the best in the class. But, then you have CJ's arm strength which is superior to Young's, so question if Young can make the zips in the short - intermediate range is valid. Nevertheless, both have talent and their demerits, but still both would be worthy of the #1 selection. I'm indifferent on the direction the Panthers take and trust their evaluation whether it be Stroud or Young. Only way I'd be mad is if it were neither of those two...lol.

Saw an interesting chart recently. All the more on topic considering the Panthers QB choices. It appears there is no correlation between QB height and batted passes. What matters more is how well the QB avoids telegraphing throws and manages himself, not height. Source

The Panthers certainly would be an outlier if they did not have Young as QB1, given from a variety of sources most of the league has him at top. I'd say from a preliminary standpoint, the Panthers traded up likely with Young in mind, and unless somehow something changes their mind in the next month, I'd say they're pretty much zero'd in on him.

Cam Newton posted this recently. An interesting thing to watch for, though it likely has no relevance to the current Panthers:

Now I normally don't pay much heed to random "NFL update" accounts, but what's intriguing is seeing their history of getting stuff right.

For a guy Vikings fans clamor is washed, it is interesting to note that his supposed zero separation is not as bad as they would claim it is. Sure, his best days are likely behind him, but he certainly does not appear to be done just yet. Could very well still have a bit of gas in the tank, and hopefully the Panthers use it to their advantage. At the least, his veteran presence and red zone production is a positive add to a young WR room, and a great swiss army knife for a rookie QB to utilize.

Wonder how much of that $10 million is a signing bonus, which spreads the cap hit.

Adam Thielen - the Ricky Proehl to Carolina's young WRs

Correction:

Apparently an Evero connection and a big dude per Broncos fans. Former Clemson player. I don't know anything else about this guy though.

Foreman should be cheap hopefully.

Wonder what this means for Alvin Kamara...

Per this tweet from a source who's personally connected with the RB in question, appears Panthers are part of the mix in aiming for Jamaal Williams of the Lions. Unsure if this implies that Foreman is gone, or if it's just due dilligence, but interesting to note we're a part of this.