UNCrules2187

While I largely agree here, my only quibble is the 5 of 6 key positions accounted for bit. Accounted for in the sense we have someone there? Yes. TBD on whether or not they are the actual answers or no: QB - rookie #1 overall pick; way too early to tell if he's a hit or not LT - 6th overall pick, young, shows flashes, seems to have regressed/struggled more than expected so far but willing to give more time DT - agreed, but he'll be seeking a big, big raise after this year DE/Pass Rush - for now...if this team starts 1-5/0-6 and Burns still doesn't have a new deal, I wouldn't be surprised to see him dealt CB - can't agree here; when healthy, Jaycee is a lockdown corner, but so far the guy will have missed at least 22 of a possible 39 games (14 in '21, 4 in '22, minimum 4 in '23 and that's giving him credit for the Atlanta game where he got hurt before halftime and it will be more than that given he's probably not coming back until the 2nd half of the year at best). Until he can be shown to be relied upon for at least 80% of a season, not sure you can say we have CB locked down

I know you have to evaluate every move on its own, but if that happened, the sequence of events you're describing would essentially mean we turned CMC, DJ Moore, Brian Burns, and 3 2nd round picks (23 SF, 24 CAR, 25 CAR) into Bryce Young and DJ Johnson.

Feels like Icky was getting beat like a drum time and again. The rest seems to match the eye test IMO.

We actually materially outgained Atlanta week 1 (20 1st downs to 13, 281 total yards to 221, 9.5 min TOP advantage), we just coughed the ball up 3 times to 0 and committed 9 penalties for 66 yards.

CMC = 23 SF 2nd, 23 SF 3rd, 23 SF 4th, 24 SF 5th Trade up to Chicago for 1: DJ Moore, #9, 23 SF 2nd (#61), 24 CAR 1st, 25 CAR 2nd DJ Johnson: Package 23 SF 3rd and 23 SF 4th So essentially, CMC + DJ Moore + 24 CAR 1st + 25 CAR 2nd = Bryce Young, DJ Johnson and 24 SF 5th

I think the thing that chaps most Panthers fans' asses is not just the draft capital but the proven talent we sent out as well. Chicago traded a 1st, 5th, 1st, and 4th for Fields. The sequence of events that got us to Bryce (+ DJ Johnson, a 25yo rookie that got 0 snaps week 1 and a healthy scratch week 2) was basically trading CMC, Moore, 2 firsts, and a 2nd. That's actually a helluva lot more capital than what Chicago invested in Fields. Nevermind that we could've just taken Fields at 8 overall (yes that means no Jaycee but he's played in a total of 17 of a possible 36 games so far in his career so are we really missing much?) that year or taken Howell without trading any picks like we did to get Corral.

Whoops, def an oversight. Still not great that we haven't been able to draft any offensive skill players worth a damn in the 21st century.

Yep...Terrace seems to be a Jarrett level bust. Even Funchess and Colbert had decent seasons. Funchess year 3 put up 63/840/8 and Colbert as a rookie did 47/754/5. I doubt we ever see a line like that from Marshall as a Panther unfortunately.

4-13 / 5-12. Only potential wins I'm seeing are vs Texans, vs Colts, at Bears, vs Bucs, and vs Falcons . We'll probably drop one of those, but maybe we surprise and win a game like at Bucs, at Saints, or vs Packers. Reich-led teams historically never start well so I don't feel confident in the next 4 (at Seahawks, vs Vikings, at Lions, at Dolphins). Frankly feels like we're staring 0-6 in the face. Maybe 1-5 if we upset the Vikings at home. 2018: 1-5 2019: 4-2 (actually started 5-2 before ending 7-9) 2020: 4-2 (best season, finished 11-5) 2021: 1-4, finished 9-8 2022: 3-5-1, fired 2023: 0-2 and staring 1-5/0-6 in the face

Our pass D and pass rush looks good, surprisingly. Burned a few times over the top, but given the CB injuries and our offense going 3 and out like 6 out of 8 drives or whatever, bound to happen. The run D looks as suspect as ever. We don't have a true NT and the OLBs are light/not good run defenders, so maybe should've expected that. But through 2 weeks, the run D ranks 29th in EPA/play.

Agreed. Sunk cost fallacy. Yesterday's price is not today's price. Fitt fumbled the ball with that (non)move, but if you're not prepared to pay Burns $28-30m per then you gotta move him.

Send Marshall with Burns, former 2nd round pick, maybe he can rejuvenate his career with Chase and Burrow.

The Panthers have never been able to draft offense well in the 2nd round...look at the history: 2023: Jonathan Mingo - too early to tell 2021: Terrace Marshall - not looking good 2019: Greg Little - bust 2017: Taylor Moton - best 2nd round pick of the 21st century by far, stalwart RT 2017: Curtis Samuel - gadget player, injury prone 2015: Devin Funchess - bust 2012: Amini Silatolu - lmao 2010: Jimmy Clausen - lmao 2007: Dwayne Jarrett - bust 2005: Eric Shelton - bust 2004: Keary Colbert - bust 2003: Bruce Nelson - played only 15 games in his career, bust 2002: DeShaun Foster - good player 1996: Muhsin Muhammad - all time Panthers great Outside of Moton, by far the best offensive players selected in the 2nd round happened 21 and 27 years ago. Think about that, it's fuging wild.

I'm not sure...just trying to think of teams that might be desperate enough to package a 1st for Burns. Looks like they've got $85m-plus cap space next season but a poo ton of FAs. I don't think you're getting Higgins, a 1, and a 2/3 for Burns though given he also needs/wants a massive deal. We'd probably have to send a pick back at that point.

I mean it's been over a half decade since the team last made the playoffs. The Panthers are 29-55 (.345) since Tepper took over. Started 0-2 4 of the last 5 seasons and in the one season that had a good start, the team proceeded to go 2-12 over the final 14 games. Why should this place be pleasant?

I don't think it'll happen, but if we can get Higgins and the Bengals 24 first for Burns, I'd do that deal in a heartbeat.

https://x.com/espnstatsinfo/status/1703965995155804606?s=46&t=TyPNsVcMFhB651jT1wRDxA

https://x.com/tompelissero/status/1703965090825851028?s=46&t=TyPNsVcMFhB651jT1wRDxA

https://x.com/rapsheet/status/1703964100433248429?s=46&t=TyPNsVcMFhB651jT1wRDxA

Another season over by week 2. Sucks.

Henderson just getting picked on over and over

Jesus Christ another TO?

Game management early into this staff’s tenure is looking pretty suspect. Hope we don’t need that TO…

Slim pickings at WR - Jarvis Landry, Kenny Golladay, Julio Jones, Sammy Watkins, TY Hilton. Maybe Hilton given he's familiar with Reich and may have some speed left?

For an “all star” coaching staff, this is some sloppy fuging play