panthers55

Scared to answer a question in a message board? Are you in middle school? How bizarre.

Why would I. Who says I would do things like McAdoo is doing or even agree. I can tell you the rationale without agreeing. Honestly we won't know if it is the best idea until things play out. I just wait to bitch until there is actually a reason. Unlike you who always has an opinion informed or not.

Again good questions for Ask Bill or email to McAdoo. Willis isn't a Panther so why should I care what he does unless we play them.

You assume people are holding Corral back. What if he were having difficulty getting our complicated offense down. Baker said it was different from what he has seen before and was more complicated. Maybe he needs mostly mental reps. I really don't know but no one is going to say he is struggling.

Corral was insurance in case we didn't get Baker and it was leverage to get a better price on Baker since drafting Corral meant we didn't need to trade for one. When we got Baker that changed the urgency with Corral and made PJ totally expendable. He is only here to share reps in camp while Corral gets things down. From what Baker said this offense is complicated. Why is it hard to believe that Corral is struggling absorbing everything that even Baker said was tough.

Unless the understudy was brought in to fix his bosses screw upset and the little boss was told by the big boss to let the understudy do his job or he might have his job.

Obviously no one knows for sure what Tepper said but we know the official line of him supporting Rhule belied the narrative he was upset and embarrassed by his mistake in hiring Rhule and the poor results. The narrative has been that football guys came in who have head coach experience to fix the football side. Guys who have strong egos and lots of experience. Why bring them in and micromanage them. If you were McAdoo would you be OC if you couldn't design and run the offense. And Rhule would be a fool to try and overrule McAdoo especially when you have failed on your own the first 2 years.

Answer this. If we didn't sign Baker would MC be getting more reps and would there be a much bigger push to get him developed. When we got Baker it changed everything. He will be the starter. PJ is simply insurance in the event Corrall takes longer to learn the playbook and translate it to the field. Hopefully no one sees the field beside Baker at QB

How many mental reps did Rodgers get behind Favre. Honestly I don't know do you?? Why is this such a big deal when likely McAdoo is controlling QB reps.

Corral was insurance that once we got Baker could be brought along slowly.

No. You.keep saying the same thing and again talk to McAdoo he obviously has a plan that you can like or hate. It isn't my plan and until I was on the field how could I know what is happening behind closed doors. I just told it to you I can't understand it for you.

Again you know that getting mental reps is what you do until you know what you are doing. Maybe as a linemen it is easier but as a QB the majority of work is mental not physical. Especially for a rookie coming from a really simple system.

We were in negotiations during the draft to acquire Baker before we got Corral. https://theathletic.com/3407839/2022/07/08/baker-mayfield-trade-panthers-browns-details/

And again each year is different. You surely know that.

I see a pattern in your thnking.....

PJ is getting reps because Corral isn't ready and Rhule is likely helping him audition for another team or play on the practice squad and come in an emergency. What else makes sense for McAdoo.

And he was a disaster why would we replicate that with Corral?

No you are trying to say we should do it like everyone else and I think you ignore the rest and focus on your team. There isn't just one way to do it.

Who follows the reps that a third stringer gets? Who cares if he sits on the bench what happens. Again why all the focus in a project. Did Greer generate pages of back and forth??

You are another one who doesn't get it. Baker and Darnold are getting starter reps because they are going to be QB1 and QB2 and we need 2 starters since they both have injury histories. And Corral is a project who isn't the focus with Rhule's focus on winning now. Seems obvious.

Again each team does what they think is best for them. Why be so dense.

It was tongue in cheek.......

Thought Pickett like Jones last year were considered the most pro ready while Corral was considered a project. Apples and oranges

Does Eli count.

Seems we have covered this already. You need 2 guys who can start in this league since both Baker and Sam missed games last year. And Corral is getting what he can handle. You need to be on the sidelines until you know what to do when you get on the field. The hype was great physicals but didn't operate in a prostyle offense.. They are doing him a favor bringing him along slowly.