Christian Mccaffrey or Alvin Kamara?

[TheCableGuy]

if you had a redraft and know what you know now who would you take?

 

to me I don't think it matters I don't see Shula using Kamara any better and I think Mccaffrey would ball out in the saints offense so for us I don't think it really matters they both great players but with Shula here it don't matter.

[uncfan888]

Another quality thread from the village idiot

[TheCableGuy]

Just now, thebigcat said:

Kamara 

do you have any faith Shula would use him any better?

 

[Thanatos]

Kamara and I wouldn't think twice.

He's going to be a thorn in our side for 10+ years.

They are both very elusive, but Kamara also breaks tackles a lot, something Cmac fails to do.

[therealmjl]

Sean Peyton

[TheCableGuy]

3 minutes ago, Thanatos said:

Kamara and I wouldn't think twice.

He's going to be a thorn in our side for 10+ years.

They are both very elusive, but Kamara also breaks tackles a lot, something Cmac fails to do.

true about the thorn part but the good news Brees will not be there for 10 more years so that kinda eases the pain.

 

also I think Christian would be just as good in that offense our problem is shula.

[uncfan888]

1 minute ago, mjligon said:

Sean Peyton

This is the only good answer but trolls gonna troll 

[dpm0409]

@TheCableGuy if the narrative of every response you provide in this thread is "Problem is Shula"......then why even ask the question in your OP to start with??  It makes the original question a moot point...

[Thanatos]

12 minutes ago, TheCableGuy said:

true about the thorn part but the good news Brees will not be there for 10 more years so that kinda eases the pain.

 

also I think Christian would be just as good in that offense our problem is shula.

I don't. The difference is Kamara breaks tackles, Cmac does not. He would be better in payton's offense, but not as good as kamara is right now.

[beastson]

Wrong post

[juliosantos]

to be fair kamara would not do poo for us , shula is trash and our oline cant run block , cmc would be great on the poodats

[tiger7_88]

28 minutes ago, TheCableGuy said:

if you had a redraft and know what you know now who would you take?

 

to me I don't think it matters I don't see Shula using Kamara any better and I think Mccaffrey would ball out in the saints offense so for us I don't think it really matters they both great players but with Shula here it don't matter.

I'll take Christian McCaffrey under Sean Payton over Alvin Kamara under Mike Shula.

Blee dat.

[Cary Kollins]

Karama would probably go top ten in a redraft.

He's looking like the best RB in the NFL.

[TheRed]

Just now, Cary Kollins said:

Karama would probably go top ten in a redraft.

He's looking like the best RB in the NFL.

Todd Gurley says hello.