Would you make this trade?

[top dawg]

Not saying it's Johnson's fault. He plays for the Lions. But Marshall has been the beast that Johnson was supposed to be, stats wise.

I can't believe no one would make this trade. Steve Smith has one, maybe two more good years in him. Marshall should be a top receiver for six or seven years to come. Orton and Moore is basically trading one limited QB for another, only Orton has more experience.

I understand you, and perhaps I'm being a bit of a homer, but with the skill, heart and desire that Smitty possesses, I don't see why he can't be an impact receiver for five more years. You're talking about Steve frickin' Smith, perhaps the most explosive WR regarding YAC that you will ever witness. great WRs don't lose their skills overnight. I think he will have to be respected for at least another 3 years.

Not really a believer in Orton. I know it could be wrong, but he reminds me of

a young Jake.

[Swarly]

http://www.nfl.com/players/brandonmarshall/profile?id=MAR370922

http://www.nfl.com/players/calvinjohnson/profile?id=JOH088640

The stats disagree with you.

http://www.nfl.com/players/kyleorton/profile?id=ORT716150

Orton: 3800 yards, 21td, 12int

http://www.nfl.com/players/matthewstafford/profile?id=STA134157

Stafford: 2267 yards, 13td, 20 int

Also: with that logic, Derrick Mason and about 23 other WR's are better than Smitty..

[DaCityKats]

ummmm i think marshall is better than cj right now.

[Steel Panther]

No way do I EVER make that trade!!!

:rofl:

[GoreMetalJunkie]

Matt Moore and Steve Smith to San Fran for Montana and Jerry Rice.

Yeah sure.

[King Taharqa]

Why do so many Panther employees want us to get rid of Steve Smith? Dont yall like being employed. You get rid of the show, who's gonna come to the games? LOL.

[DaCityKats]

kt what you think about the thomas trade?

[King Taharqa]

kt what you think about the thomas trade?

Another example of a front office that wants to "win at all costs" and is constantly trying to get better. Rod Higgins has done a fine job as our GM since he got here in 06. I like Thomas and I think his range and athleticism make the Bobs even better.

[MadHatter]

The Moore vs Orton thing is interesting. Moore has more upside, but he is also unproven.

Marshall just brings too much baggage and continued off the field issues. I agree that talent wise and age wise, it might be something to think about.

Due to the baggage, I would have to say NO.

[Matt Foley]

The Moore vs Orton thing is interesting. Moore has more upside, but he is also unproven.

Marshall just brings too much baggage and continued off the field issues. I agree that talent wise and age wise, it might be something to think about.

Due to the baggage, I would have to say NO.

What's funny is that fans of every other team in the League look at Steve Smith and think he comes with more baggage than anyone else in the League. If our team trades for TO, we get some buffoon who complains when he doesn't get the ball enough. If they trade for Steve Smith, we'll have fights in the wide receiver film room.

[SOJA]

Matt Moore and Steve Smith to Denver for Orton and Brandon Marshall.

[Guild]

No sorry.

I won't bother with a cerebral response. My heart says no and the question stops there.

[PantherPhann]

matt moore and steve smith to denver for orton and brandon marshall.

wtf

[Argus Plexus]

No. Smitty stays for as long as he can still play. I say, with the cap space left from Peppers ducking out of dodge, I'd say get a proven talent like Steve Breaston. I was campaigning for them to snag Anquan Boldin rather than tag Peppers, last offseason. That would have been domination. Smitty AND Boldin on the field AT THE SAME TIME ON THE SAME SIDE. *Fantasizes about how dominating they would be together.* Smitty in the slot like he wants, and Boldin out there snagging Moore TD's all over the damn place. OMG, tag Peppers NOW and trade him for Boldin. DO IT NOOOOOOWWWW!!!