Should Brian Cushing be stripped of is R.O.Y. award?

[Dpantherman]

with the recent positive steroid violation, people are beginning to ask, so I'll ask you all, should he be stripped of Rookie of the Year?

[Dpantherman]

and of course, Pie is always an option, just not in the poll

[Swarly]

nope. if people think that he's the only one who's won an award on steroids they need to step back into the real world.

[Lout]

Merriman was a beast when he was on steriods.. now he is mediocre..

[Swarly]

Merriman was a beast when he was on steriods.. now he is mediocre..

I'm sure the serious season ending knee injury had nothing to do with that.

[rodeo]

i'm the only one who feels they'd need more info?

what was the substance? actual steroids or just penis pills like that olympian?

[coxc63]

Yea simply for the fact that he had to cheat to get the award, like Bonds did in baseball.

[Dpantherman]

i'm the only one who feels they'd need more info?

what was the substance? actual steroids or just penis pills like that olympian?

thats why the option is in there.

[carolinapanther4life]

No, what's done is done.

[House]

i'm the only one who feels they'd need more info?

what was the substance? actual steroids or just penis pills like that olympian?

Which Olympian? The he-she that runs track and field? I thought shim was on anti-penis pills.

[House]

No, what's done is done.

Why don't you come over here and tell that to my neighbor. He is still pissed I knocked up his old lady.

[pantherclaw]

Do I think he deserved the roty award knowing he has tested positive? No, he doesn't deserve it.

But no, ya can't strip him of the award. Just like ya can't strip the patriots of their lombardi trophys even though they were cheating. The past is the past.

[Wither]

Why don't you come over here and tell that to my neighbor. He is still pissed I knocked up his old lady.

How much Cialis did you take to accomplish that?

[SorthNarolina]

if there not going to strip O.J. or L.T. of their awards then hell no should they strip cushing for using some steroids.

The NFL wouldn't do simply because if they strip him of the award they could very well give it to a guy who is also roided up.

And what constitutes roids as cheating? If a guy uses steroids once in his career is he forever a cheater and undeserving of awards? What about if he used them a ton in college but not in the pros? What if he used them during the SB but not during the regular season?

You can't really strip a guy of an award, theres too many variables involved.