J-Stew not a top 10 RB in madden 11

[Lilsmitty09]

http://www.pastapadre.com/2010/06/29/madden-11-player-ratings-top-10-rb

HBs

Chris Johnson (TEN) – 99

Adrian Peterson (MIN) – 98

Maurice Jones-Drew (JAX) – 96

Steven Jackson (STL) – 95

Frank Gore (SF) – 93

DeAngelo Williams (CAR) – 92

Ray Rice (BAL) – 90

Michael Turner (ATL) – 90

Ronnie Brown (MIA) – 89

Cedric Benson (CIN) – 89

Anyone wanna explain to me how the hell Cedric Benson and Ronnie Brown are better then J-Stew? and why steven jackson is so high?

[Beason n Smitty beaston]

its cuz stew plays on the panthers....

[Lilsmitty09]

its cuz stew plays on the panthers....

so does deangelo?

[g5jamz]

I'd probably sadly have to agree...he's just outside the top 10.

I have a problem seeing him beat out by Benson...but that's about it. Benson was on a crappy team and still did relatively well last year. If Stewart has a injury-free season and puts up 1000 yds again...that will probably change when Madden updates mid season.

[Brandon]

Yet more reasons (as if we needed them) to ignore the Madden franchise.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

DeAngelo should've been third on that list, in my opinion.

[g5jamz]

Remember...Madden isn't accounting for team Oline strengths or offenses. Just their individual talent. If you took Steven Jackson and put him behind the Panthers O-line...how do you think he'd do. And I'm not saying DeAngelo is NOT better than Steven Jackson. Personally I see DW around 4th...just beating out Gore and Jackson, but I'd also put Rice right up there with him. Just my personal opinion and in no way defending Madden, but just trying to give perspective.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

J-Stew and Jamal Charles should be on there.

[g5jamz]

Yeah...JCharles is insane good and was on a crappy team. He should beat out Benson for the 10th spot.

[R0CKnR0LLA]

My top 10 would be...

Chris Johnson (TEN)

Steven Jackson (STL)

Adrian Peterson (MIN)

DeAngelo Williams (CAR)

Maurice Jones-Drew (JAX)

Frank Gore (SF)

Ray Rice (BAL)

Jonathan Stewart (CAR)

Jamaal Charles (KC)

Ronnie Brown (MIA)

[Peppers90 NC]

That's a shame. I am sure Stew is very upset that a video game doesn't have him ranked in the top 10. Even though most of those guys are more proven and featured backs. R Brown is a proven back, injuries are his downfall. Benson carried the Bengals offense to the playoffs.

[DickolausJ]

I'd probably sadly have to agree...he's just outside the top 10.

I have a problem seeing him beat out by Benson...but that's about it. Benson was on a crappy team and still did relatively well last year. If Stewart has a injury-free season and puts up 1000 yds again...that will probably change when Madden updates mid season.

You know they made the playoffs and won their division right?

[beastson]

Once the season ended, Stew was better than half of those on the list

Top 10 in rushing yards, with much less attempts and much better avg.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

I love how nobody mentions Michael Turner.