Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

ESPN: Panthers have "worst group of D-tackles in the league"...


SnarkAttack

Recommended Posts

http://espn.go.com/blog/nfcsouth/post/_/id/10849/carolina-weakness-defensive-tackle

Steve Smith broke his arm and outside of him, this team has had very little in terms of receiving options of late. Without him, the Panthers will be among the weakest teams in this regard in the NFL -- even with a few rookie pass-catchers added to the equation. It seems as though there is a good chance Smith will be ready for the opener, but even if he is unable to go, the Panthers have a bigger weakness than their pass-catchers.

Even the most casual of fans realize Carolina lost Julius Peppers during free agency, but there is some young talent there in Charles Johnson and Everette Brown. At defensive tackle, Damione Lewis and Maake Kemoeatu are gone, and what remains is frankly very disturbing.

[+] EnlargeEd Wolfstein/Icon SMI

The Panthers traded for Louis Leonard last September, but he played in only two games before breaking his ankle.As of today, the foursome that should expect to see playing time at tackle consists of Nick Hayden, Louis Leonard, Tank Tyler and Corvey Irvin. And maybe Ed Johnson or Derek Landri will factor in. Seriously? Let me just go on record to say that this is the worst group of defensive tackles in the league, and I am not even sure that dubious competition is close.

I understand you can sometimes get away with tough guys who play hard and hold their ground at this position to help free up those around them, and I understand that several of these guys battled injury last season, but there isn’t a playmaker in this bunch, nor is there a guy who commands a double-team in the run game. Compounding matters for the long term, there isn't a young pup in the group who has yet to develop and is dripping with upside. I really don’t see a lot of hope here.

The Panthers’ run defense wasn’t very good last season. With this group of defensive tackles and now the loss of LB Thomas Davis (knee injury), expect it to be even worse in 2010. If the defense can’t get off the field, it will certainly make playing a ball-control, run-first style on offense all the more difficult.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Compounding matters for the long term, there isn't a young pup in the group who has yet to develop and is dripping with upside

While one could argue on the "dripping with upside" opinion.

Tank, leonard, and Irvin are young players that are either really young (irvin) or placed in schemes they didn't really fit into (Tank/Leonard).

I still hate we didn't go after Corey Williams.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I do not honestly think it's that bad, not even close to worst in the league. Kemo and lewis wern't all that great to begin with.

They definitely will not be the worse when its all said and done, but right now, can we think of a team with less proven options? I wish I could but I can't

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One name comes to mind when I think of this situation...

Jordan Carstens

This guy came in for Jenkins when Jenkins went out with a injury and played extremely well.

The reason I bring him up is because everybody seems to be doubting our DTs but lets wait until pre-season and see what they can do before judging.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This guy came in for Jenkins when Jenkins went out with a injury and played extremely well.

The reason I bring him up is because everybody seems to be doubting our DTs but lets wait until pre-season and see what they can do before judging.

'Tis a good point. At one time, we had a bunch of no-names on our offensive line, many of which turned out very, very well for us. I can only hope we have the same success with some of these guys on our defensive line.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One name comes to mind when I think of this situation...

Jordan Carstens

This guy came in for Jenkins when Jenkins went out with a injury and played extremely well.

The reason I bring him up is because everybody seems to be doubting our DTs but lets wait until pre-season and see what they can do before judging.

Carstens routinley beat double teams, he was a huge find. Too bad he had those blood clots.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They definitely will not be the worse when its all said and done, but right now, can we think of a team with less proven options? I wish I could but I can't

Yeah I am basing that on a few things. I think people overate kemo and lewis tremendously, they aren't going to be hard to replace. I don't think our scheme demands anything that these guys can't do. I also think they will play well based on how they looked earlier before injury.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • My general thoughts on the roster as it stands right now:  - Most interesting positions to watch: TE, NT, WR.  - If we add a TE I feel like it'll be a bigger name FA or Kenyon Sadiq in the 1st round. I don't expect us to take a TE that early with our need at tackle, though, so it's likely one of the top FA TEs or we ride with Tremble/Sanders/Evans again. Signing a mid-level FA or drafting another mid-round TE isn't going to help us at this point. We have three of those guys already.  - I don't buy the 1st/2nd round WR hype. I do think we will sign someone to play the slot because XL is... not good. John Metchie, Juan Jennings and Calvin Austin would make sense if the money does.  - NT could be interesting because I don't get the sense that they view Bobby Brown as a true starter. This could be a position we look to add a veteran starter at or possibly take one early in the draft.  - Devin Lloyd was a huge addition, but we need another starter beside him. I fully expect us to go after one in the 2nd round. Jacob Rodriguez makes a ton of sense here.  - The Luke Fortner signing gives us a veteran fallback at center this season. I don't expect he'll end up being our long-term starter, but it's likely he will at least begin the year atop the depth chart. Even if we draft a center it's unlikely that player ends up being a day-one starter. But I think right now we're likely targeting a center in the 3rd-4th round as that seems to be where the value is.  - We have no punter on the roster. Interested to see if we sign a veteran or go the draft/UDFA route.  - The OT situation is pretty bleak. I now fully expect us to take a tackle at #19, but even after the Stone Forsythe signing we also need better depth there. Brady Christensen would be an idea re-signing; I also like Jamaree Salyer from the Chargers as a younger option that still has room to develop.  - Guard depth is also lacking. Again, having a versatile backup like Brady Christensen would go a long way toward having some security for our entire OL, but even if he comes back we should add another veteran backup, IMO.  - I assume Lathan Ransom would be the starting FS if we played today, but we know Evero loves him some Nick Scott so I won't be surprised if/when we re-sign him. He's basically the defensive version of David Moore, unfortunately. Ideally we'd look to add a true FS, but I don't get the sense that is a big priority at the moment.  - Nickel corner is a need and I fully expect us to sign someone in the next few days to upgrade over Chau Smith-Wade. Long-term, I won't be shocked if we go CB earlier in the draft than people might expect given Mike Jackson's contract expires after this year.  - I wouldn't be shocked to see us sign a RB. Sean Tucker or Brian Robinson could be interesting. We know what Chuba can do, but Jonathon Brooks has to be considered a question mark at this point.
    • Considering the Raiders and Crosby’s disagreements about his health late last year and the Ravens’ history of being an extremely well run organization I lean towards the Ravens not being in the wrong here
    • Hoping for Chig as the TE signing.  N'joku and Goedert are more proven and names, but give me the guy entering his prime that hasn't missed a game over the older guys with better stats but injury history. 
×
×
  • Create New...