Better Comeback: 05' Smitty Vs. '10 Vick

[Montsta]

Bleacher report had an interesting article (can someone link, I'm on phone browser and it is teh suck) on the 25 best comebacks of the decade. They gave Vick 2010 the top spot, whereas triple crown Smitty got #7. I thought it was ridiculous, but my homer glasses are welded on permanently so maybe I'm wrong. Thoughts?

Oh, and Delhomme got #24 for 2003.

Edit: link http://www.bleacherreport.com/articles/563332-michael-vick-and-the-25-best-comeback-players-of-the-decade

[frash.exe]

it's bleacher report

[csx]

it's bleacher report

and who cares anyway?

[Ricky Spanish]

this list actually isn't poo. i'm surprised from a bleacher report article.

[Fiz]

vick came back from, ahem, personal trouble and put together his best year as a QB after a year of sitting on the bench. he did this on an absolutely stacked offense.

smith came back from a broken leg and put together one of the best years for a wide receiver ever, won the triple crown, and did this on a team where the second leading receiver was a running back.

[MaineManPanther]

With Smith, you had a feeling he was about to break out a big season. You also knew he would have his chance, he was starting.

Vick was out of football for two years, and wasnt expected to be able to run like he did, let alone take his passing game to another level.

[Dingo_ate_Babies]

Mark Fields' comeback from cancer should have been on the list.

[Makish]

Mark Fields' comeback from cancer should have been on the list.

f@## yeah

[Matthias]

Definitely '05 Smith, his team went further in the playoffs. On another note, Steve Smith didn't really win the triple crown. He lead in receiving yards, but tied in receiving touchdowns and receptions that year. Yet I guess they say that is good enough, but I'm not satisfied with that title considering he isn't the sole leader in all three categories. Smith's nickname used to be Captain YAC, it's time he brought that one back.

[Ricky Spanish]

Mark Fields' comeback from cancer should have been on the list.

the magnitude of his comeback kind of took a hit (no pun intended) when he was arrested for beating his wife a couple times.

[Mr ocho nueve]

Trying to be as non-homeristic as possible, I say Smith. Only because the guy broke his leg, you know, the body part that he needs to run really fast. Maybe Vick if he got shanked in prison.

[Jackofalltrades]

Smith came back from a broken leg, Vick came back from being a piece of shat, he shouldn't be in the league or in the list.

[bleys]

vick came back from, ahem, personal trouble and put together his best year as a QB after a year of sitting on the bench. he did this on an absolutely stacked offense.

smith came back from a broken leg and put together one of the best years for a wide receiver ever, won the triple crown, and did this on a team where the second leading receiver was a running back.

well said.

[Lite4Nite]

Smith was expected to do that. No one knew if any good would come out from Vick. Top spot should go to Vick, but Smith could jump ahead 1 or 2 spots IMO