Damning indictment of Bryce Young

[Jon Snow]

Just now, strato said:

I accept that that is what he is, I don’t accept settling. I say keep looking. Keep taking shots. Absent any clear improvement from his current inconsistent performance. 
He has had a couple of good ones but they are not followed with more good ones. 

I don't think anyone is settling on him except maybe the team. Im not sure how long that will last. As of today and for the remainder of this season he's the best we have. 

[strato]

4 minutes ago, Jon Snow said:

I don't think anyone is settling on him except maybe the team. Im not sure how long that will last. As of today and for the remainder of this season he's the best we have. 

Nah, I am not even talking about this year. This is the home stretch for him to show what he has and I totally accept that. 

Edited October 27, 2025 by strato

[Jon Snow]

1 minute ago, strato said:

Nah, I am not even talking about this year. This is the home stretch for him to show what he has and I totally accept that. 

Im not sure you haven't seen everything already. What you've seen is all there is to see. There's not magical evolution that's going to take place where he turns into the next Drew Brees or Patrick Mahomes. You've seen his best and worst. The worst far outweighs the best.

[strato]

21 minutes ago, Jon Snow said:

Im not sure you haven't seen everything already. What you've seen is all there is to see. There's not magical evolution that's going to take place where he turns into the next Drew Brees or Patrick Mahomes. You've seen his best and worst. The worst far outweighs the best.

Allow me to clarify as I am sure you don’t catalog everything I post but there is some qualifying that statement that was done.

I think the Dallas game was his ceiling. He played well for the whole game and didn’t phuck it up and contributed some nice throws. 
 

What he hasn’t done is follow that level of performance with a duplicate. And that one with another. 
No consistency. He is up and back down to date and that is clear as it can be, there should be no arguing that from anyone. He is a roller coaster. 2023 Green Bay, very promising. Followed by two shutouts. 
The end of 2024, followed by the beginning of 2025. 
The best stretch he has is 6 quarters, 2nd half Miami and the Dallas game. MAybe there is another 6 quarters somewhere but that is it. 
So I am looking for him to hit his ceiling and keep that floor a lot higher in this stretch of games. 

Edited October 27, 2025 by strato

[Jon Snow]

13 minutes ago, strato said:

Allow me to clarify as I am sure you don’t catalog everything I post but there is some qualifying that statement that was done.

I think the Dallas game was his ceiling. He played well for the whole game and didn’t phuck it up and contributed some nice throws. 
 

What he hasn’t done is follow that level of performance with a duplicate. And that one with another. 
No consistency. He is up and back down to date and that is clear as it can be, there should be no arguing that from anyone. He is a roller coaster. 2023 Green Bay, very promising. Followed by two shutouts. 
The end of 2024, followed by the beginning of 2025. 
The best stretch he has is 6 quarters, 2nd half Miami and the Dallas game. MAybe there is another 6 quarters somewhere but that is it. 
So I am looking for him to hit his ceiling and keep that floor a lot higher in this stretch of games. 

Well I don't think he will ever be consistent. He will always be up or down with his play. Mostly down.

[strato]

7 minutes ago, Jon Snow said:

Well I don't think he will ever be consistent. He will always be up or down with his play. Mostly down.

Well we have these games for it to play out how it plays out. 

[bythenbrs]

We are screwed.  I’ve seen enough senior management ego and hubris to continue on a disastrous path rather than admit a mistake.  

Edited October 27, 2025 by bythenbrs