CRA's All Time Panther QB Rankings

[Yup]

14 hours ago, CRA said:

never logged a start

He was named the starter and was heir apparent to Beuerlein until his preseason collapse.

 

The way they were hyping the guy up at the time you'd have thought he was the next Montana or Young.

[kungfoodude]

This is a hilariously bad list.

[Pantherxtreme]

Teddy Bridgewater had three 1000 yard receivers that has never been done in Panthers history outside of that, he was better than any Qb on that list not named Newton, Delhomme, Collins, Beuerlein.

1.Newton - MVP, Superbowl 2015

2.Delhomme - Most successful tenure, Superbowl 2003, NFC championship loss 2005.

3.Collins - 2nd year starter led us to NFC Championship 1996.

4.Beuerlein - Best pure passer, single season leader in pass yards.

5.Bridgewater- Highest QB completion 69.1 % in franchise history for a season.

[toldozer]

Id put Derick Anderson and Vinny t above Bryce. Anderson was good the first season he was here and Vinny t threw some absolute dimes and obliterated the cardinals at like 47 years old

[strato]

3 minutes ago, toldozer said:

Id put Derick Anderson and Vinny t above Bryce. Anderson was good the first season he was here and Vinny t threw some absolute dimes and obliterated the cardinals at like 47 years old

Off the couch. 

Edited November 7, 2025 by strato

[Packersfan]

I’ve never gotten Panther fans input but do you guys think that 96 team you had was good. I obviously would say the 2015 team was your best team ever.

[toldozer]

2 minutes ago, strato said:

Off the couch. 

Played the way flacco is with the bengals. Just chuck it to the best guy. Smith 10 for 136 and a TD. I remember him having like 350 yards passing but it was only 206. So my point still stands, he cracked 200 yards he goes over Bryce.

[strato]

8 minutes ago, toldozer said:

Played the way flacco is with the bengals. Just chuck it to the best guy. Smith 10 for 136 and a TD. I remember him having like 350 yards passing but it was only 206. So my point still stands, he cracked 200 yards he goes over Bryce.

We could probably pull someone off the couch to do what Bryce is doing plus add a couple more things to the playbook. 
That was a crazy year. 

[Pantherxtreme]

24 minutes ago, Packersfan said:

I’ve never gotten Panther fans input but do you guys think that 96 team you had was good. I obviously would say the 2015 team was your best team ever.

96 Defense led league in sacks and lowest points allowed.

Offense wasn't spectacular but very balanced.

1 thousand yard back and Collins had 2 sure handed receivers along with all pro Wesley Walls at Tightend. 

2015 had opportunistic defense, Norman, Davis, Kuechly, and crew strong run game with Cam and Stewart, underrated passing attack. 

2003 was probably the best overall team, Steve Smith's and Musin Muhammad in their prime, Steven Davis plowing over people, and Julius Peppers and Kris Jenkins and crew dominating in the trenches.

 

 

Edited November 7, 2025 by Pantherxtreme

[strato]

And Morgan at MLB when he stayed healthy, was a beast. Something like 25 tackles in that Super Bowl I think. 

I know the younger people are all about Cam and 2015 but that 2003 was my favorite year. It came out of nowhere which made it kind of magical. 

 

Edited November 7, 2025 by strato

[joeyxfresco]

Looking back Teddy was a good QB for what we were trying to build. The Rhule stink and the teams handling of Cam to make room for Teddy and then Teddys handling to make room for Darnold is one of the darkest times in this franchise 

[CRA]

8 hours ago, KaseKlosed said:

List is all over the place. Trash list 

sorry, I asked AI and it didn't put Bryce Young at the top

[CRA]

2 hours ago, kungfoodude said:

This is a hilariously bad list.

post a good list.  Outside of Teddy B being low (which I conceded I messed him up)......no one really has pointed out anything notably out of whack. 

[CRA]

for fun I did ask AI and it had Bryce Young right above Matt Moore and Rodney Pete.   It's reasoning of getting Bryce where it got is really giving Bryce an edge thanks to his number of starts and career yardage.