Best and worst PFF grades from Panthers' Week 12 loss to 49ers

[mav1234]

10 hours ago, Waldo said:

He looks good but after his tape was out there he also came back to earth a bit too. I wouldn't put him near where CMC was for us tho. That's a whole other teir....so far. 

I think we need to see him with competent QB play first. Dalton couldn't stay healthy for a drive so we really haven't seen who he really is yet on the field. It's really hard for me to evaluate him with the current playbook from a full view.

Oh man he's no CMC, I said since CMC for a reason haha. But I don't think he's come down to earth - he had the best game of his career not long ago.

He just still makes some mistakes but it's things I believe he'll clean up.

[Basbear]

11 hours ago, kungfoodude said:

That hope is unlikely to pay off. He has consistently regressed as a player.

Im going to give him more time and hopefully a new panther QB will be tossing him darts next year. 

It feels, rough numbers and all- Tmac 60% Coker 15% Rico/chubba-20% XL- 3% Sanders/TEs- 2% of attention/targets etc. 

[Waldo]

3 hours ago, mav1234 said:

Oh man he's no CMC, I said since CMC for a reason haha. But I don't think he's come down to earth - he had the best game of his career not long ago.

He just still makes some mistakes but it's things I believe he'll clean up.

Come down to earth is post game 3 or 4 from memory. CmC put up crazy numbers in a crazy time here. That is like comparing other good D guys to Luke or Peppers IMO. Not a knock either just a reality check. Could he? I don't know in this set up honestly. CMC was a freak while here, even hurt at times. 1k and 1k is some next level stuff. Im happy if Tet is 1k+ for the year. 

[mav1234]

32 minutes ago, Waldo said:

Come down to earth is post game 3 or 4 from memory. CmC put up crazy numbers in a crazy time here. That is like comparing other good D guys to Luke or Peppers IMO. Not a knock either just a reality check. Could he? I don't know in this set up honestly. CMC was a freak while here, even hurt at times. 1k and 1k is some next level stuff. Im happy if Tet is 1k+ for the year. 

Sorry, I think perhaps what I meant isn't clear. TMac is our best player on offense we've had since CMC left. I don't think he's in the same tier right now (though perhaps some day)