Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Replacement for Basanez/Competition with Moore?


methodtoll

Recommended Posts

We don’t need a fourth quarterback to compete with Moore, we need someone to compete with Delhomme. The jury is still out as to whether Moore or McCown can be effective starters in the league. I’m willing to give either a shot, but right now I don’t see either one being a better option as a starter than Delhomme.

I really think this is the year we draft a quarterback, perhaps in the second round. They may not see the field much next year, but it’s time to start thinking about grooming someone to replace Jake, and perhaps even compete for the job (which is probably a long shot for a rookie quarterback under John Fox).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We don’t need a fourth quarterback to compete with Moore, we need someone to compete with Delhomme. The jury is still out as to whether Moore or McCown can be effective starters in the league. I’m willing to give either a shot, but right now I don’t see either one being a better option as a starter than Delhomme.

I really think this is the year we draft a quarterback, perhaps in the second round. They may not see the field much next year, but it’s time to start thinking about grooming someone to replace Jake, and perhaps even compete for the job (which is probably a long shot for a rookie quarterback under John Fox).

As I mentioned before, getting a QB in the draft will all depend on what they do with Peppers. If we can somehow come away with at least a 1st round pick + say, a 3rd rounder then I think they can be safe enough to use a later pick on a QB. However, if we do not trade Peppers this year, I believe that we probably won't invest in a QB. If we did, it will most likely be a cheap free agent pick up.

One possibility that no one really has mention is the possibility of Kyle Boller coming here. I know a lot of people are not really high on him and will be much comparable to Carr but if my memory serves me correctly, Fox and Hurney, at one point back in 06, were looking at trading for Boller.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As I mentioned before, getting a QB in the draft will all depend on what they do with Peppers. If we can somehow come away with at least a 1st round pick + say, a 3rd rounder then I think they can be safe enough to use a later pick on a QB. However, if we do not trade Peppers this year, I believe that we probably won't invest in a QB. If we did, it will most likely be a cheap free agent pick up.

One possibility that no one really has mention is the possibility of Kyle Boller coming here. I know a lot of people are not really high on him and will be much comparable to Carr but if my memory serves me correctly, Fox and Hurney, at one point back in 06, were looking at trading for Boller.

Think you are right on Peppers and picks. We really are in good shape as far as the draft (not needing much). If we get some extra picks I could see them using one to pick a QB. I dont think they will get one in F/A though as we have two quality QB's behind Jake I think we will live and die by those three and the 4th will be either stashed on the practice squad or play another position (white) while learning to be a qb.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4th QB? Did Gruden get hired on the Panthers our sumpin'? You must mean for the practice squad.

lol, that's what I'm saying... starting threads about a 4th QB?

Who cares who the 4th is.... He'll never see playing time anyhow. Even if it comes down to a 4th QB, chances are someone will be brought in, i.e. Testaverde and 2007...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4th QB? Did Gruden get hired on the Panthers our sumpin'? You must mean for the practice squad.

lol, that's what I'm saying... starting threads about a 4th QB?

Who cares who the 4th is.... He'll never see playing time anyhow. Even if it comes down to a 4th QB, chances are someone will be brought in, i.e. Testaverde and 2007...

:lol: :lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am so sorry that I didn't make a repetitive thread about where Peppers was going and who will be a replacement for him

I am so sorry that I didn't make a repetitive thread about how Jake Delhomme sucks and we need a new starter at QB

and I am so sorry that I didn't make a repetitive thread about where Ken Lucas will be cut or traded.

Maybe, just maybe, instead of creating multiple threads on the same topic that we could, actually talk about something else for a change.

In regards to this, we have always had 4 QBs at the start of summer school and training camp and well into Pre-season. I am just saying that maybe we could always bring another QB in to compete with Moore for the third spot.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am so sorry that I didn't make a repetitive thread about where Peppers was going and who will be a replacement for him

I am so sorry that I didn't make a repetitive thread about how Jake Delhomme sucks and we need a new starter at QB

and I am so sorry that I didn't make a repetitive thread about where Ken Lucas will be cut or traded.

Maybe, just maybe, instead of creating multiple threads on the same topic that we could, actually talk about something else for a change.

In regards to this, we have always had 4 QBs at the start of summer school and training camp and well into Pre-season. I am just saying that maybe we could always bring another QB in to compete with Moore for the third spot.

You're exactly right. I really do appreciate this thread for that. I guess with all the daily panic threads, it's easy to read this as another.

However, for discussion, last year Lester Ricard had a few praises. I couldn't see anyone with drastically more skill to come in. It will be someone similar of a Basanez or Ricard skill type..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Every year folks on here and talking heads constantly talk about us drafting a quarterback.

Fox isn't going to do it. The one guy he drafted, Lefors. didn't last 2 years. He hasn't done it since and has made it clear that he doesn't think a rookie quarterback is worth the money to develop. He would much rather get a guy who is a free agent and has been around the league. It is much more likely that we will pick up a guy like Chris Simms or another free agent than we will draft a quarterback.

I expect that all you guys unhappy with Jake hoping we are going to draft a QB in the first day will be disappointed again. Fox likes Jake, McCown, and Moore.

I wouldn't be surprised if we don't even pick up one in free agency. I for one would be fine with picking up one or two guys but it is far from a foregone conclusion that we will.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Canales’ recipe for success is simple — slow the game down with long drives that keep the other team’s offense off the field. Long drives are built from short gains but short gains require more 3rd-down conversions.  The Panthers are converting 37.5% of their third downs, which is average but not enough. As a result, they have attempted 21 fourth downs — the most in the NFL — and they’ve converted 71.4% of them, ranking 3rd among teams with at least 15 attempts. The Chiefs are second @ 80% and the Colts are first at 88% but the majority of their conversions are short yardage runs - not passes.  The Panthers have had three big wins this season — against Miami, the Cowboys, and the Packers — those conversions have played a major role in each of those wins. Miami The Panthers trailed by 17 in the 2nd quarter, facing a 4th-and-5 at the Miami 48. Young threw a 21-yard completion and they went on to score 7 on that drive. Then in the 4th, down by 4, they faced another 4th-and-5 at the Miami 33. Young delivered a 17-yard completion for the 1st down and they went on to score the winning TD. Cowboys The game is tied and the Panthers take over at their own 14 with 6 minutes left. Rico picks up 16 yards and Young converts two 3rd downs, gaining 37 yards, but misses on a third conversion. At the Cowboys’ 40, facing a 4th-and-4 at the 2-minute mark — knowing the Cowboys likely score if they get the ball back — Canales has them go for it. Young converts with a 7-yard pass putting them at the 33 in FG range. They then go on to kicj the game winning FG. Packers Young was 2-for-2 on 4th-down attempts. Then on the final drive starting from their own 19 with the score tied, Young converts two 3rd downs for 19 yards and Rico adds another 19 to move them into field-goal range for the win. In total, Bryce went 2-for-4 on 3rd downs and 5-for-5 on 4th downs on critical plays in those games. When the Panthers needed 1 yard against the Packers on their own 41 early in the game, Canales went to Young. - not Rico. When they needed 4 yards to keep the drive going at the 2 minute mark against the Cowboys he went to Young. Those throws weren’t empty-yardage completions; they were high-pressure, must-convert moments that directly contributed to all three wins. I keep reading how the Panthers  are winning in spite of Young, that Canales doesn’t trust him and schemes around him. But these drives show the opposite: when the game is on the line, Canales has consistently put the ball in Young’s hands and Young has consistently produced in those moments.  Some people do well in normal situations but crumble under pressure. Others can be uneven in normal times but produce when the presure is greatest. The question is who would you rather have in the playoffs. More importantly, who do you think Canales and the FO would want?  
    • I think is worse news for Tremayne. They need special teams help with him questionable.  If T-Mac is down, XL, Coker, Horn, and Renfrow. No way Chisena gets meaningful snaps as WR, only on special teams. 
×
×
  • Create New...