A qb poll ....

[C47]

Arron Rogers.

If Jimmy lights it up you let Cam sit and learn. You hold on to him as long as you can because with every passing month the game slows down that much more.

Beyond that, with the rookie salary structure there is no pressure to rush him into the fire. He can sit for a few seasons without breaking the bank.

Way different scenarios...Brett Favre was 37...Jimmy Clausen is 23 and can play for another 15 years...

[C47]

My point wasn't how many candles go on the cake.

We've all known for years that QBs that had a chance to spend a season or 3 holding a clipboard are always better off. Give Cam that chance. Let him watch a successful QB run an offense and let him learn. With his rookike contract there is time and cap space to allow for it.

So if Jimmy lights it up, embrace the opportunity to groom our next QB and make the decision to play Cam or move on when we have to decide on that 5th year option on his contract.

So you move on with nothing instead of getting great value (as proposed in this hypothetical scenario)....didn't we already do that with Peppers...

[RockyTopVol]

I'm afraid that a more realistic question would be, if they both suck it up, do we still go after Luck in next year's draft.

[Mr. Burgundy]

aint happenen anyways

[Shufdog]

Trading Newton is so ridiculous..

Not only noone would give you a first round because if you are ready to trade Newton for a first rounder you know something they don't and so noone will deal with you.

Anyway Newton is a Carolina Panthers QB, speaking of trading him after 2 weeks make you look like an hamburger eating surrender monkey.

Give this kid a year and let him play at time, then we will speak about him next season.

What the hell is a hamburger eating surrender monkey??? :confused:

[C47]

What the hell is a hamburger eating surrender monkey??? :confused:

Like I said...swag for creativity....

[fam4life09]

no comment

[bigjohn]

We trade both of them so we can draft Andrew Luck, since Luck is going to be better than Joe Montana, Michael Jordan, Mickey Mantle, Wayne Gretsky, Frank Sinatra, and Al Pacino combined.

Oh wait, that was the conversation on this board 6 months ago.

[Jpjr]

Wait this thread is about trading Cam when Jimmy lights it up this year. Do you honestly think that if any QB, not just Jimmy, puts up the kind of number in the OP that any team would trade them? Regardless of who is sitting behind them? WOW

Absolutely. Cam Newton is the future of this franchise. Clausen has the opportunity to become a Kevin Kolb. The difference is that the Panthers won't pay a backup QB with starting credentials $10mm+ a year when Clausen decides to hold out for a better contract or trade in 2012. Again.. all assuming he is lights out and of course this thread has already jinxed that lol.

[MadHatter]

What the hell is a hamburger eating surrender monkey??? :confused:

I don't know.....but I like it....funny as hell.

[blackcatgrowl]

I'd send Jimmy Jam to the Raiders for a first round pick and a player.

Him hitting numbers like that would be an freak thing, and probably not reliably consistent for a stretch of his career.

[natty]

Whatever happens to Cam is up to Cam. You roll with Jimmy as long as he's playing well and let Cam's progress determine what you do with him.

[Shufdog]

I don't know.....but I like it....funny as hell.

I googled it and came up with this.

But anyway, back on topic, you play Clausen and let Newton wait his turn.

[Toundra]

What the hell is a hamburger eating surrender monkey??? :confused:

I have heard the cheese eating thing so many time, the answer is simple just insert a national meal/food and here you go.

:sad::nopity::devil:

Sushi eating surrender monkey, Gulash eating surrender monkey, Couscous eating surrender camel etc.