Should I take this trade?

[Jeff L]

I get Pierre Thomas and Larry Fitzgerald and give up Vincent Jackson and Miles Austin. Here is the rest of my roster:

QB Kevin Kolb, Ari QB

RB LeSean McCoy, Phi RB

RB Reggie Bush, Mia RB

RB/WR Steve Smith, Car WR

WR Andre Johnson, Hou WR

WR A.J. Green, Cin WR

TE Greg Olsen, Car TE

OP Miles Austin, Dal WR

D/ST Chargers D/ST D/ST

K Sebastian Janikowski, Oak K

BENCH

Bench Vincent Jackson, SD WR

Bench Ryan Grant, GB RB

Bench Michael Crabtree, SF WR

Bench Thomas Jones, KC RB

Bench Tarvaris Jackson, Sea QB

Bench Jerome Harrison, Det RB

Bench Brent Celek, Phi TE

Bench Redskins D/ST D/ST

Thanks for any advice!

[Johnny Rockets]

I wouldn't even consider it. Pierre Thomas basically has no value.

Why is VJax on your bench? He should start over AJ Green and Smith.

[The Saltman]

because he is going by last weeks numbers and not by matchups

[Jeff L]

Actually Salt, the starters above are who I started last week. I just haven't had time to change them for this weekend.

Here is his roster:

QB Michael Vick, Phi QB

RB Beanie Wells, Ari RB

RB Pierre Thomas, NO RB

RB/WR Mark Ingram, NO RB

WR Larry Fitzgerald, Ari WR

WR Santana Moss, Wsh WR

TE Kellen Winslow, TB TE

OP Matthew Stafford, Det QB

D/ST Patriots D/ST D/ST

K Shaun Suisham, Pit K

Bench

Bench Steven Jackson, StL RB

Bench Lance Moore, NO WR

Bench Michael Bush, Oak RB

Bench C.J. Spiller, Buf RB

Bench Chad Henne, Mia QB

Bench Ben Tate, Hou RB

Bench Shaun Hill, Det QB

Bench Ed Dickson, Bal TE

He wants Miles Austin and Vincent Jackson off of my squad... He told me he would give me Fitzpatrick who I would love to have; (double points with Kolb) who else should I ask for?

Thanks for the help fellas!

[X-Clown]

I wouldn't trade Austin and V Jax who both are top 10 receivers to get the guy who might end up at #2 for a receiver and a running back who splits touches with two others. Sometimes the best moves you make are the ones that you don't make at all.

[X-Clown]

Jeff L, I hope to god you didn't make that trade...:lol: If you didn't, you probably raped and pillaged the poo out of whoever you played this week.

[Jeff L]

Lol... I did not make the trade! I knew it was a bad trade but the guy that proposed it was talking a lot of poo. I just wanted to make sure my gut feeling was right. Bad news is Austin is out for at least this week!

[Dpantherman]

yea, they tried to poo you. Basically a 2 for 1 deal in their favor. New Orleans is RB by committee. And Thomas isn't seeing a whole lot of action.

[CarolinaNCSU]

Tavaris Jackson? Come on man. You need another RB. Try giving some of those WR's up to even your talent levels at all positions. WR is great. RB all ya got is McCoy.

[DRSundrop]

how about this trade?

payton hillis

for

devery henderson

reggie bush

lions defense

[X-Clown]

how about this trade?

payton hillis

for

devery henderson

reggie bush

lions defense

I can't forsee a circumstance that this trade would be beneficial for you if you are the one giving up Hillis. How do you see the trade helping your team?

Reggie Bush is already starting to lose carries to Daniel Thomas, Devery Henderson will struggle to put up consistent numbers with all the weapons that they have in the offense (even without Colston in the lineup), and the variance that you would get on defenses week to week usually wouldn't make that much of a difference. Also you likely will have to drop 2 players from your roster to make that deal.

[DRSundrop]

i offered the trade. the person had patriots defense only 1 good wr and obviously bush would be a downgrade to hillis.

[The Saltman]

If he does it he is a complete moron.

[X-Clown]

i offered the trade. the person had patriots defense only 1 good wr and obviously bush would be a downgrade to hillis.

Oh in that case if he takes it, he's a lunatic and congrats on the ripoff.