Your all Panthers line-up

[Bronn]

QB - Newton

HB - Stewart

FB - Griffith

WR - Smitty

WR - Moose

TE - Walls

LT - Gross

LG - Wharton

C - Kalil

RG - Wahle

RT - Terry

LE - Peppers

DT - Jenkins

RE - Rucker

OLB - Greene

MLB - Beason

MLB - Mills

OLB - Witherspoon

CB - Gamble

FS - Grant

SS - Minter

CB - Davis

K - Kasay

P - Baker

KR - Bates

ST - Cooper

Honorable second teamers:

QB - Beurlein

RB - Williams

FB - Hoover

WR - Carrier

WR - Ismail

TE - Mangum

T - Brockermeyer, Otah

G - Donnalley, James

C - Mitchell

DE - Wallace

DT - Kragen

DE - Fox

OLB - Lathon

MLB - Morgan

OLB - Davis

CB - Cousin

S - Maxie

S - Harris

CB - Poole

K - Akers

P - Sauerbrun

KR - Smart

ST - Hankton

[jb_online]

There are some guys I don't remember all that well. I know Buckner was the one who used to kiss his cleats once for everyone in his family, right? I forgot that Cota was SS and not FS. I have trouble keeping those two positions straight.

So people don't like Willig? I remember him being HUGE and maybe that's why I liked him then, but I don't remember him being a bad player... what was the problem with him?

Wasn't Mills a MLB?

Thanks guys.

Whoa, nice list jsquared!

[adub2b23]

I still think dwill in his prime > stew in his prime

[Mvp2014]

they are both in their prime now.

[SCMunnerlyn1]

QB Jake Delhomme/Steve Buerlien (sp?) / Cam Newton

FB Brad Hoover

HB Deangelo Williams / Johnathan Stewart / Stephen Davis

WR Steve Smith / Mark Carrier

WR Muhsin Muhammed / Raghib Ismail

TE Wesley Walls / Kris Mangum

OT Jordan Gross / Travelle Wharton

OG Travelle Wharton / Kevin Donnalley

C Ryan Kalil / Jeff Mitchell

OG Mike Wahle / Geoff Hangartner

OT Jeff Otah ( when healthy ) / Blake Brockermeyer

DE Julius Peppers / Charles Johnson

DT Kris Jenkins / Jordan Carstens ( I liked him when he played here )

DT Brentson Buckner / Maake Kemoeuatu

DE Mike Rucker / Al Wallace

OLB Will Witherspoon / James Anderson ( yea I said it )

MLB Sam Mills /Jon Beason / Dan Morgan

OLB Kevin Greene / Lamar Lathon

CB Chris Gamble / Ken Lucas

FS Deon Grant / Charles Godfrey

SS Mike Minter /Chris Harris

CB Eric Davis / Ricky Manning JR ( pre rule change )

K John Kasay

P Todd Sauerbrun

KR Michael Bates / Steve Smith

PR Steve Smith

ST Ace : Karl Hankton / Captain Munnerlyn ( Had to go somewhere xD)

[TNPanther]

QB Delhomme (let's not be so quick to crown Cam)

RB Williams, Davis, Stew

FB Hoover

WR Smitty

WR Moose

WR Proehl

TE Walls, Olsen

LT Gross

LG Wharton

C Kalil

RG Wahle

RT Willig, Otah when healthy (yes, pathetic)

LE Peppers

NT Jenkins

DT Buckner

RE Johnson, Rucker

LOLB Davis, Mills

MLB Beason, Morgan

ROLB Witherspoon

CB Gamble

CB Lucas

NB Manning, Jr.

FS Maxie

SS Minter

K Kasay (tough one!)

P Sauerbrun (when he wasn't busy juicing or being an asshole)

LS Jansen

ST Hankton

KR He Hate Me

PR Smitty

[TNPanther]

double post

[Bronn]

Don't crown Newton, in favor of Delhomme, but yeah go ahead and mention Olsen along with Walls... lol

[OneBadassCat]

QB- Steve Beurlien, Cam Newton, Jake Delhomme

RB- Deangelo Williams, Johnathan Stewart, Deshaun Foster

FB- B. Hoover

WR- Steve Smith, Mushin Muhammad, Rocket Ismail(sp?), Ricky Proehl

TE- Wesley Walls, Greg Olsen

LT- Gross

LG- Wharton

C- Kalil

RG- Mike Whale

RT- Otah

DE- J.Peppers, Charles Johnson

DE- Mike Rucker, Kevin Greene

DT- Kris Jenkins, B. Buckner, Kemoatu

LOLB- Thomas Davis, Will Witherspoon

MLB- Dan Morgan, Jon Beason, Sam Mills

ROLB- James Anderson, Mark Fields

CB- Chris Gamble, K. Lucas, Ricky Manning Jr.

SS- Mike Minter, Chris Harris

FS- Chad Cota, Deon Grant

KR/PR- Michael Bates

That's all madden baby

[panfan32]

I almost choked when I read Kevin Green at MLB. Hes always been a strong side OLB. Never played inside or even in a 4-3 defense.

[JJT]

No Todd Sauerbrun?

Led the team in personal fouls.

[Mr ocho nueve]

What the hell is Cam doing at #1 Qb on some of these lists? This is ridiculous.

[Moose87Banks]

Kevin Greene over Jon beason lol

[panfan32]

What the hell is Cam doing at #1 Qb on some of these lists? This is ridiculous.

I agree. Now hes had one hell of a rookie season, but lets see where he sits in 3-4 more seasons before we say hes the best QB Carolina has ever had. I would put Steve Beuerlien.

Steve 2 and 3/4 year stats

Yards: 10779

TD: 72

INT: 45

QBR: 87.5

Jake Delhomme: His best 3 seasons with us

Yards: 10595

TD: 68

INT: 43

QBR: 86.7