So Right now...Peyton or Eli?

[Dpantherman]

Eli numbers isn't touching Peyton's

So I guess you haven't seen them.

[Dilla]

Yall are talking about the teams, im talking about the QBs numbers. Eli's are better, call it what you want, can't get around it.

The team effects numbers.

[Cat'sGrowl]

Still Peyton.

But Eli is a baller no doubt. Sweet justice for him tonight after all the heat he took for saying he was in Brady's class.

[Dpantherman]

The team effects numbers.

Yea. And both teams made the superbowl twice.

Its blasphemy to say Eli and Peyton in the same sentence. i get it.

[KillerKat]

So I guess you haven't seen them.

I don't think you have yourself

Peyton:

399 TDs, 198 INTs, 54828 yards, 64.9 cmp %, 94.9 QB rating

8 All-Pro selections (most by any Qb after merger)

Eli:

185 TDs, 129 INTs, 27579 yards, 58.4 cmp %, 82.1 QB rating

0 All-Pro selections

[Dpantherman]

PSSSSSSSSST....I said PLAYOFFS. Several times in this thread. PLAYOFFS.

I said IN THE PLAYOFFS, Eli has been just as good as Peyton at this time in both of their careers. That is all I've ever said. And it said I didn't consider the gap as close as many thought.

THAT is what I said.

[KillerKat]

PSSSSSSSSST....I said PLAYOFFS. Several times in this thread. PLAYOFFS.

I said IN THE PLAYOFFS, Eli has been just as good as Peyton at this time in both of their careers. That is all I've ever said. And it said I didn't consider the gap as close as many thought.

THAT is what I said.

Then how can you sit there and say we shouldn't consider other elements of the team? Like someone said, those other elements affect the numbers. If you don't consider them, then theres no need to have a convo about these two with you.

[Penalty Flag]

Peyton in the first three quarters, Eli in the fourth.

[Dpantherman]

Who said I didn't consider them? Jesus guys, all I ever said that its close (in the playoffs).

I never said Eli > Peyton period, thats it. If I did show me and i'll apologize.

[KillerKat]

and the question was who do you pick to build a super bowl team with. you got to count regular season stats as well because you need to play good there before you even get to the playoffs. And a super bowl team is good on both sides of the ball. The colts have always been good on just 1 side of the ball. If Peyton was actually on a complete TEAM like Eli, he would have more rings.

[charlotte49er]

Looking at all the great brothers who have played professional sports over the years.

I don't think there has ever been a better pair!

Alou's (Fillipe, Manny & Mo), Brett's (Ken & George), Dean's (Dizzy & Daffy), The list is long, but Manning Bros have to be the Gold Standard!

And they aren't done yet!

[KillerKat]

Who said I didn't consider them?

Yall are talking about the teams, im talking about the QBs numbers. Eli's are better, call it what you want, can't get around it.

WTF kinda brain games are you trying to play with us!?

[Dpantherman]

and the question was who do you pick to build a super bowl team with. you got to count regular season stats as well because you need to play good there before you even get to the playoffs. And a super bowl team is good on both sides of the ball. The colts have always been good on just 1 side of the ball. If Peyton was actually on a complete TEAM like Eli, he would have more rings.

I backed off of that a long time ago. Not what I was going for. I'll help you out.

[KillerKat]

we're all drunk, time out