TLGPanthersFan

Did he only start because the head coach had no one else and went with the vet in the room?

Hypothetically, even Young or Stroud? If it is either of those I’d expect them to start sometime next year unless the team over performs and taking out the current QB doesn’t make sense because he has the hot hand.

Guess we gotta hope that Reich is the QB whisperer people think he is and he can develop a QB with the highest floor but lowest ceiling into a franchise QB, or at least a competent starter.

Hmm. Seems like Klein may know something. Interesting. If it is Darnold I expect people to freak out. If it is Jimmy G I expect some people to freak out. Darnold or any other QB not names Jimmy = Backup for rookie who can start year one. Jimmy G = Bridge for rookie who will get a red shirt year.

Then they do the exact opposite. But something tells me the Panthers wouldn’t be too unhappy to get Young if the Texans flip flopped.

The money he wants, yeah not bad. Him regressing after 3-4 games, still bad.

I have never see a system as QB friendly as the 49ers. I mean it had Brock Purdy looking like an amazing QB. Yes Jimmy G has a winning record as QB. But you have to realize that it is because of the system he is in. He was responsible for them losing the Super Bowl and the 2022 NFC Championship. He has shown during big games a great capacity to choke. As people have pointed out if we did get him it should be a 1 or 2 year deal, but with a rookie being developed behind him.

I’ve always preferred the get a young QB then build around him plan. The build a team and then get a young QB doesn’t seem to work that often. Not every team can be lucky like the Chiefs and have a complete team ready to insert a new young QB. I think building this team around a QB with a rookie deal will work well for the Panthers. Keeping a team together before you draft a rookie QB is hard because players get tired of losing and then leave or want more money and the team we built for a rookie suddenly is gone.

And possibly waiting till next year using picks to more up to get a QB could possibly have the same result. Just a different year. There are what 5 or 6 supposed good QBs right now for 2024. That number will likely shrink to 2-4. Then we are left with project players. I get peoples logic not to move up but wait till next year, pretty much keeps coming up every off-season for the last 3 years, but eventually ya gotta take a chance and if not this year then next year. BUT I guarantee that there will be people who don’t want to move up or draft a QB were we are, I predict 15+, and just wait till 2025. Vicious cycle.

You are assuming people won’t be back here next year saying that no QB in 2024 is worth our first round pick. You are also assuming we will have a QB better than this year fall to us next year. Pretty obvious that, unless the team falls off a cliff, we probably won’t be drafting high enough to get a top QB in the first round. Unless every QB coming out in the 2024 supposedly stacked class is good, they won’t be, then we will be right back where we started every off-season. Arguing the same darn thing. We have no idea if any of the QBs next year will be good and if they are we will probably still have to pay to move up and it will be expensive. Panthers won too many games this year and really put themselves in between a rock and a hard place. I don’t envy the FO of the decisions they will have to make.

Would love to see Fields with a good coaching staff and o line. Yeah a lot of his impressive plays were running but he also made some good throws that showed potential. I’d give him a chance.

Rhule not wanting to move up shows how much he doesn’t value the QB position.

A comment on an another site said that The Athletic, from an anonymous source, that Panthers may just stay pat at 9. Pretty much meaning what we all know. No one knows anything.

Gonna be funny when the Huddle turns on Carr.

Could asked the same thing when the Panther signed Darnold.

Batting 1.000 so far.

The team that is dumb enough to sign another vet cast off QB.

We are not making the Super Bowl with Carr at QB. So, yes never. Unless this team is able to get over Carrs brain fart moments that seem to rise up at the worst possible moment. Carr is Cousins. I don’t want a Cousins on this team.

I think trusting people at this stage of the game if foolish. This coaching staff on paper looks good. But if Carr is signed and the Panthers fall on their faces then trust doesn’t mean much. This coaching staff has to give me a reason to trust them. As of right now I don’t. I “nothing” them. But I hope in the future I can trust them.

Carr is just a Cousins. He may get us 12 wins but he will be the reason we never make a Super Bowl.

His funeral. Didn’t work out with Wentz. Won’t work out with Carr.

Reich wanting to take a chance that may get him fired if it doesn‘t work out. A rookie QB would give him an excuse if the Panthers don’t do well but if they fail after signing Carr it could be a short career here for Reich. I just don’t think Carr can get this team to the Super Bowl.

It is called 3 years without a franchise QB. It isn’t artificial. I hope they stay away from thinking like yours. Because you are content with mediocrity.

You apparently like having this team with no QB. Stay at 9 makes no sense. At 9 we won’t get a QB and if we do he fell to 9 for a reason.