I think Webb should be our second string quarterback

[Pejorative Miscreant]

I see this thread and envision Wal-mart on Black Friday.

Sent from my iPad using CarolinaHuddle

[pantherpain]

Every preseason it's the same thing. Cam looks kind of mediocre, and the skeptics come out of the woodwork to suggest we'd do better to start Anderson or Webb or whoever. Then the real bullets start flying and they all have to crawl back into their hiding places.

 

Some people never learn.

 

As to the original question, I too prefer Anderson over Webb. 

So how would you rate Cam on reading the D, going through his progression and putting the ball on the money.

[Marguide]

So how would you rate Cam on reading the D, going through his progression and putting the ball on the money.

 

Uh...I don't know, I'd say he's been pretty decent considering he's been the most prolific passer for the first 3 years in the history of the NFL.

 

But I'm guessing that's not good enough for you.

[pantherpain]

Uh...I don't know, I'd say he's been pretty decent considering he's been the most prolific passer for the first 3 years in the history of the NFL.

 

But I'm guessing that's not good enough for you.

Lol, no he hasn't, but I'm sure you will prove it.

[PntherPryd]

To me the point of this thread (and other recent , similar threads) is not so much about DA being a sub par backup but about how eye-openly good Webb has looked .

Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

[PhillyB]

nope

[stirs]

QB rating tonight:

 

Webb  106

DA       78

 

And for fun

 

Manziel  71

[LawCat]

DA is the backup. Without question. Knock on wood, but if Cam did go down, DA gives us a solid chance to win eveyr week. Especially if the Defense is as good as we all hope.

 

If Cam comes out week 1 and plays well and looks to be able to manage his injuries, Webb could have some legit trade value. Wouldn't mind seeing him moved for a late round pick. Webb has come in here and done everything expected of him and more. He deserves another shot at a starting gig somewhere in my opinion.

 

 

[LawCat]

DA is the backup. Without question. Knock on wood, but if Cam did go down, DA gives us a solid chance to win every week. Especially if the Defense is as good as we all hope.

 

If Cam comes out week 1 and plays well and looks to be able to manage his injuries, Webb could have some legit trade value. Wouldn't mind seeing him moved for a late round pick. Webb has come in here and done everything expected of him and more. He deserves another shot at a starting gig somewhere in my opinion.

 

 

[ForMac]

DA is better at the dink and dunk quarterback game, but CAM for this system and in general really is the better quarterback. I am very grateful to have DA though as I think playoffs isn't automatically destroyed for the season if CAM goes down. Now if CAM is showing in practice to absolutely suck because of his rib injurys and DA is visually better. Put him in and heal up CAM. Start him in TB if he can't be CAM then think about DA as starter and sub packages for Webb to keep defenses gameplanning.

[Marguide]

Lol, no he hasn't, but I'm sure you will prove it.

 

I am certain he has the most combined yards for their first 3 years of any QB in NFL history, and I'm also certain he had the most passing yards through his first 2 years of any QB in NFL history. Perhaps someone here knows if that still holds through his first 3 years.

 

Any way you measure it, his performance has been spectacular. 

 

Not sure why I bother with you frankly.

[TheRed]

I like Webb, arguing over who is better between him and DA at this point just serves no purpose.

[Kevin Greene]

DA is a major luxury for us.

If God forbid the unthinkable happens DA keeps us extremely competitive given our defense.

I've seen Webb play in Prime Time, not so pretty.

[Pox 08]

No thanks.